PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Seesmic Desktop 2

 & Jill Duffy Contributor

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
Seesmic Desktop 2 - Seesmic Desktop 2
3.0 Average

The Bottom Line

Pro social media users may find everything they need in the Seesmic desktop app—except for scheduled posting, a likely deal-breaker—after a lengthy, one-time setup. Casual users will buckle beneath Seesmic's barrage of options and features.

Pros & Cons

    • Massive plug-in library supports nearly every social media site and service.
    • Excellent customization options for social media pros and power users.
    • Supports multiple Twitter accounts.
    • Mac and PC compatible.
    • Overwhelming for casual social media users and some advanced users, too.
    • Moderate learning curve.
    • No central login to sync accounts across desktop and mobile app editions.
    • Cannot increase some painfully small text point size (though main display fonts can be resized).
    • Desktop version does not support scheduled posts.

Seesmic Desktop 2 Specs

Free: Yes
OS Compatibility: Mac OS
OS Compatibility: Windows 7
OS Compatibility: Windows Vista
OS Compatibility: Windows XP
Type: Personal

If your job description mentions Facebook and Twitter by name, you need a social media aggregator, an application that centralizes the incoming and outgoing information for multiple social networking profiles. Seesmic Desktop 2 (free) is a dossier for every account you could possibly have, from Ning to Ping.fm, and possibly some you've never even heard of, such as 6dgree and Zendesk (both are for customer service). The extensive plug-in library that lets you connect virtually any social networking platform or tool to Seesmic makes the app unbeatable for power users—except that the desktop version does not include the ability to schedule posts that you don't want to publish immediately (although you can do this in Seesmic's Web app).

Casual users will find Seesmic's features, options, and customizations too generous. The time and effort needed to set up all these add-ons and learn how to use the tool can be crushing. Even some online social butterflies will feel their productivity crippled for a day or two by Seesmic's learning curve. Most people are in better hands with HootSuite (free to $5.99 per month for Pro, 4 stars) or TweetDeck (free, 4 stars), which are just as powerful, easier to set up, and less intimidating than Seesmic. Both HootSuite and TweetDeck support scheduled posts, too.

The only reason a seasoned social media user might choose Seesmic over HootSuite or TweetDeck is for the networks and tools included in the list of plug-ins. If you only use the big three—Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn—Seesmic doesn't offer you anything over what HootSuite and TweetDeck deliver, and they're easier to learn. And if you do like Seesmic, you might as well use the Web app rather than the desktop version, as it supports scheduled posting.

Getting Into Seesmic
The Seesmic desktop client runs on Microsoft Silverlight, which makes it compatible with both Mac and Windows machines. At 4.4MB, it's a fairly lightweight application that installs quickly. Load it, launch it, and prepare to spend the next hour at least configuring and customizing it.

Connecting social media accounts is easy and takes about as much time as entering your username and password for each site, then granting Seesmic access to it. Exploring the interface and options, however, requires a lot more time.

Seesmic has four main tabs that run vertically along the left side: All, Accounts, Userlists, and Searches. ("All" shows all the accounts that you've connected in addition to everything listed in the other three tabs.) Each of those tabs has an additional menu, and within each menu, there are even more options. Some of those options have yet more selections. These are all in addition to the many sub-pages of the Options area, the back-end section where you can customize the app.

The first time I flicked through all the menus and tabs, Seesmic overwhelmed me, and it didn't get much better on the second, third, or even fourth time around. It's not that the information is disorganized, it's that there's a lot to take in regardless. Some of what appears in the hierarchical system is in fact redundant, although that's to be expected. The more complex an online system, the more key concepts should be intentionally repeated to drive home their importance to the user and make them easier to find. But intentional redundancy is also a sign that a product or interface has too much stuff in it, and Seesmic could stand some trimming.

Once you're up and running, Seesmic centralizes all the incoming and outgoing messages from the social media sites you've connected to it. Like TweetDeck, it displays different streams according to your customization, in vertical bars. For example, you can have a stream for all incoming Twitter messages from everyone you follow, a second Twitter stream that shows only messages people have sent at (@) you, a third stream that only pulls status updates from Facebook, and so on. You can drag any one of these vertical columns to a new location at any time, although the visual effect that confirms the object is being moved lagged for me every single time.

Seesmic offers additional columns you can add to the app that go beyond your connections, such as Twitter Trending; Twitter Directory, which shows a list of topics and accounts on those topics to help you find more people to follow; Channels, which reveals select businesses and the Twitter users associated with them; and Marketplace, which helps you find and add more Seesmic plug-ins.

Final Thoughts

Seesmic Desktop 2 - Seesmic Desktop 2

Seesmic Desktop 2

3.0 Average

Pro social media users may find everything they need in the Seesmic desktop app—except for scheduled posting, a likely deal-breaker—after a lengthy, one-time setup. Casual users will buckle beneath Seesmic's barrage of options and features.

About Our Expert

Jill Duffy

Jill Duffy

Contributor

My Experience

I'm an expert in software and work-related issues, and I have been contributing to PCMag since 2011. I launched the column Get Organized in 2012 and ran it through 2024, offering advice on how to manage all the devices, apps, digital photos, email, and other technology that can make you feel overwhelmed. That column turned into the book Get Organized: How to Clean Up Your Messy Digital Life. I was also the first product reviewer at PCMag to test fitness gadgets, including everything from early Fitbits to smart bras.

Currently, I'm passionate about the meaning of work and work culture, and I enjoy writing about how managers and employees can communicate better, with or without software. My most recent book is The Everything Guide to Remote Work. I also love a good workplace drama. 

In addition to writing about work, I cover online education, focusing on learning for personal enrichment and skills development. I have a soft spot for really good language-learning software. Although I grew up speaking only English, some twists and turns in life led me to learn Spanish, Romanian, and a bit of American Sign Language. I've studied at the university level, as well as at the Foreign Service Institute, where US diplomats and ambassadors learn languages.

My writing has also appeared in WIRED, the BBC, Gloria, Refinery29, and Popular Science, among other publications.

Follow me on Mastodon.

The Technology I Use

Squeezing every last bit of usage out of the devices I already own is the only way I can tolerate my personal consumption. In other words, I do not own the latest cutting-edge technology. I buy things that will last and try to take care of them.

My life is organized by Todoist, and my notes live in Joplin. Where would I be without Dashlane as my password manager? Probably locked out of all my many online accounts—I have more than 1,000 of them.

When I share my contact information, it's an excruciatingly long list of phone numbers, messaging apps, and email addresses, because it's essential to stay flexible while also remaining somewhat mysterious.

Read full bio