PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

These Are the Top 20 Nintendo Games of the Decade

From the dark days of Wii U to the triumph of the Switch, here are Nintendo's best games of the 2010s.

 & Tony Polanco Considering everyday life mundane, Tony prefers to spend most of his time absorbed in fictional worl

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

You Can Trust Our Reviews

Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. Read our editorial mission & see how we test.

Deeper Dive: Our Top Tested Picks

  • Super Mario Odyssey (for Nintendo Switch)

    Super Mario Odyssey (for Nintendo Switch)

    5.0 Exemplary

    Pros & Cons

      • Fun, varied gameplay.
      • Many kingdoms to explore and challenges to beat.
      • Capture mechanic adds exciting problem-solving elements.
      • Costumes and Snapshot mode are a blast.
      • Very limited multiplayer.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Super Mario Odyssey isn't just the best Nintendo Switch game yet, it's the best Mario game since Super Mario Galaxy.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Get It Now
  • The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (for Nintendo Switch)

    The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (for Nintendo Switch)

    4.5 Outstanding

    Pros & Cons

      • Massive, diverse open world.
      • Tons of clever puzzles.
      • Wide variety of things to see and do.
      • Strange desaturation filter makes the game appear hazy.
      • Combat is frustrating early on.
      • Weapon durability is a nuisance.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild is the biggest, most impressive Zelda game yet, and a fantastic launch title for the Nintendo Switch.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Super Mario 3D Land - Nintendo 3DS

    Super Mario 3D Land - Nintendo 3DS

    4.5 Outstanding

    Pros & Cons

      • The best use of the 3DS screen to date.
      • Excellent control and level design.
      • Themes are all over the place.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Super Mario 3D Land stands as one of the best 3DS games yet, and one of the best non-remake reasons to get a 3DS.

    Specs & Configurations

    ESRB Rating: E for Everybody
    Genre: Action Games
    Platform: Nintendo 3DS
    Get It Now
  • Luigi's Mansion 3 - Nintendo Switch Standard Edition

    Luigi's Mansion 3 - Nintendo Switch Standard Edition

  • Bravely Default

    Bravely Default

    4.0 Excellent

    Pros & Cons

      • Very well-polished.
      • Nostalgically satisfying.
      • Understands and adapts to the flaws of the old-fashioned JRPG genre.
      • Derivative story.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Bravely Default is the best new Final Fantasy game I've played in years, and it isn't even a Final Fantasy game.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Games
    Product Games ESRB Rating T for Teen
    Product Games Genre Role-Playing
    Product Games Platform Nintendo 3DS
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Metroid: Samus Returns (for Nintendo 3DS)

    Metroid: Samus Returns (for Nintendo 3DS)

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Get It Now
  • Super Smash Bros. Ultimate (for Nintendo Switch)

    Super Smash Bros. Ultimate (for Nintendo Switch)

    4.5 Outstanding

    Pros & Cons

      • The biggest roster yet.
      • Loads of content, spanning dozens of video game series.
      • Polished, satisfying gameplay with lots of variety.
      • Lacks proper online ranking tiers.
      • No online tournament mode.
      • Collectible spirits lack context and detail.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Super Smash Bros. Ultimate for the Nintendo Switch earns its title, standing out as the most comprehensive Smash game to date.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Bayonetta 2 (for Nintendo Switch)

    Bayonetta 2 (for Nintendo Switch)

    4.5 Outstanding

    Pros & Cons

      • Fast, responsive combat mechanics with plenty of depth.
      • Excellent graphics.
      • Looks great and plays well in both docked and portable mode.
      • Physical version includes original Bayonetta.
      • Fairly short as a single playthrough.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Bayonetta 2 was one of the best action games on the Wii U, and the Switch port makes it so much more accessible.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Fire Emblem: Three Houses

    Fire Emblem: Three Houses

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Get It Now
  • Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

    Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

    4.5 Outstanding

    Pros & Cons

      • Completely overhauled Battle Mode.
      • Tons of tracks, including DLC content.
      • Lots of local and online multiplayer options.
      • Some stuttering with four-player split-screen in testing.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is the second must-buy game on the Nintendo Switch (after The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild), and it's the most comprehensive Mario Kart game to date.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Pokemon Sun (for Nintendo 3DS)

    Pokemon Sun (for Nintendo 3DS)

    4.0 Excellent

    Pros & Cons

      • Best-looking mainline Pokemon game to date.
      • Alola trials mix up and vary progression over the gym-and-badge system, breathing new life into the game for longtime fans.
      • Ride Pagers improve overworld navigation.
      • Starts out very slow.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    The newest Pokemon generation, Sun/Moon for the Nintendo 3DS, tweaks and polishes the series' core concepts and remixes enough ideas to feel fresh without making any wild, polarizing changes to the formula.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo 3DS
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze (for Nintendo Switch)

    Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze (for Nintendo Switch)

    4.0 Excellent

    Pros & Cons

      • Creative, varied level design.
      • Looks great.
      • Funky Kong mode makes the game more forgiving for less skilled players.
      • Adds very little besides Funky Kong.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze is another excellent Wii U game that has found an even better home on the Nintendo Switch.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle (for Nintendo Switch)

    Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle (for Nintendo Switch)

    4.0 Excellent

    Pros & Cons

      • Deceptively deep, complex gameplay.
      • Tons of maps and challenges.
      • Well-executed, fun premise.
      • Squad sizes are limited.
      • No online or competitive multiplayer modes.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle combines one of the most beloved names in video games with a horde of manic, cartoon rabbits for a surprisingly satisfying turn-based strategy experience.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Splatoon 2 (for Nintendo Switch)

    Splatoon 2 (for Nintendo Switch)

    4.0 Excellent

    Pros & Cons

      • Just as fun and frantic as the first game.
      • Improved graphics.
      • More local multiplayer options than the first Splatoon.
      • Online matches are still heavily curated.
      • Doesn't change much from Splatoon.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Splatoon 2 on the Nintendo Switch feels more like an updated, expanded Switch port of the first game than a sequel, but that's pretty compelling on its own.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch)

    New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch)

    3.5 Good

    Pros & Cons

      • Two full-length games.
      • Varied levels.
      • New easy characters make certain challenges friendlier.
      • Difficulty curves for both games are still harsh.
      • Doesn't offer much new content from the previous version or earlier New Super Mario Bros.
      • games.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe bundles New Super Mario Bros. U and the much, much harder New Super Luigi U into a single package on the Switch. The combo will satisfy any fan of old-school Mario platformers.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
  • Xenoblade Chronicles 2 (for Nintendo Switch)

    Xenoblade Chronicles 2 (for Nintendo Switch)

    3.5 Good

    Pros & Cons

      • Huge game world, with lots to do.
      • Sprawling, eye-catching landscapes.
      • Deep combat system.
      • Mechanics feel overly complicated at times.
      • Character design is very generically anime.
      • Annoying texture and object pop-in bugs.

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Xenoblade Chronicles 2 for the Nintendo Switch is a massive JRPG you can play at home or on the go, but if you aren't already familiar with the Xenoblade series, its design and scope can be bewildering.

    Specs & Configurations

    Product Category Nintendo Switch
    Product Price Type Direct
    Get It Now
These Are the Top 20 Nintendo Games of the Decade

Compare Specs

Select Up To 3Select Up To 2
Our Pick
Rating
5.0 Exemplary
4.5 Outstanding
4.5 Outstanding
4.0 Excellent
4.5 Outstanding
4.5 Outstanding
4.5 Outstanding
5.0 Exemplary
4.5 Outstanding
4.5 Outstanding
Best For
Product Price Type
DirectDirectDirectDirectDirectDirect
Product Games Platform
Nintendo 3DS
Product Games Genre
Role-Playing
Product Games ESRB Rating
T for Teen
Product Category
Nintendo SwitchNintendo SwitchGamesNintendo SwitchNintendo SwitchNintendo SwitchNintendo SwitchNintendo Switch
Platform:
Nintendo 3DSNintendo 3DS
Genre:
Action GamesAction Games
ESRB Rating:
E for EverybodyE for Everybody

Buying Guide: These Are the Top 20 Nintendo Games of the Decade

About Our Expert

Tony Polanco

Tony Polanco

Considering everyday life mundane, Tony prefers to spend most of his time absorbed in fictional worl

Considering everyday life mundane, Tony prefers to spend most of his time absorbed in fictional worlds that stimulate his imagination. Tony is a geek through and through, and his love for comic books, science fiction, heavy metal, and video games knows no bounds. He uses his natural writing talent and communication skills to express to the world why it's awesome to live a geek-centric lifestyle. Tony is a former contributor to DualShockers and current executive editor for The Koalition.

Read full bio