PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch) Review

 & Will Greenwald Principal Writer, Consumer Electronics

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch) Review - Consumer Electronics
3.5 Good

The Bottom Line

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe bundles New Super Mario Bros. U and the much, much harder New Super Luigi U into a single package on the Switch. The combo will satisfy any fan of old-school Mario platformers.
Best Deal£47.19

Buy It Now

£47.19

Pros & Cons

    • Two full-length games.
    • Varied levels.
    • New easy characters make certain challenges friendlier.
    • Difficulty curves for both games are still harsh.
    • Doesn't offer much new content from the previous version or earlier New Super Mario Bros.
    • games.

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch) Specs

Product Category Nintendo Switch
Product Price Type Direct

Nintendo sometimes gets very weird with how it names games. It doesn't quite hit Kingdom Hearts levels of nonsense (I'm looking at you, Kingdom Hearts 2.8 HD Final Chapter Prologue), but it comes close. New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe is one of the best examples. This $59.99 game for the Nintendo Switch isn't new like the first part of its name suggests, and it isn't for the Wii U like the fifth part of its name suggests. It's a port of the 2012 Wii U game New Super Mario Bros. U, with the New Super Luigi U standalone DLC game included. It's lots of side-scrolling Mario action in an inexpensive package, with a few extra Switch-exclusive features, one of which is that you can play it on your TV or on the go.

"New" Super Mario Bros.

New Super Mario Bros. U was the fourth game (and arguably fifth, too, if you count New Super Luigi U) in the New Super Mario Bros. subseries, which Nintendo spun off from the main Mario series of 3D platformers like Super Mario Odyssey. The NSMB games are pure side-scrollers in the style of the 8- and 16-bit Mario games, built around leading Mario (or Luigi, or any other playable character) through obstacle-course-like levels until they reach a flag pole at the end or, in the case of towers and fortresses, beat a boss. New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe is very simple and direct, with a premise to match: Princess Peach has been kidnapped by Bowser and you need to rescue her.

We've looked at both New Super Mario Bros. U and New Super Luigi U in detail in our reviews of the Wii U games, and little has changed in New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe. The action is still tight and responsive, the level designs are still clever, and the world is satisfyingly varied and big. Mario's side-scrolling antics look just as good on HDTVs and 4K TVs now as they did when NSMBU first took the video game icon to 1080p in 2012. And, of course, New Super Luigi U is still incredibly difficult, posing a stressful and time-limited spike in challenge from NSMBU's own sharp and uneven difficulty curve.

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe

Enter Toadette

The biggest change in NSMBU Deluxe is the addition of Toadette as a playable character. The original let you choose between Mario, Luigi, and two differently colored Toads, supporting up to four simultaneous players at once. One of the Toads has been swapped out for Toadette, the pink-colored, pigtailed Toad girl. She functions as a slightly easier way to play the game.

While Mario, Luigi, and Toad all play similarly, Toadette skids less on slippery surfaces and gets three extra lives instead of one, spawning 3-Up moons from blocks that would ordinarily give 1-Up mushrooms. Toadette can also collect Super Crown power-ups that turn her into Peachette—a version of Princess Peach with pigtails. Peachette can float short distances, and perform a second jump in mid-air, giving her capabilities similar to those other characters get when equipped with the Flying Squirrel Suit. Peachette also gets extra chances when she falls down bottomless pits or touches lava or poison, launching out of the situation once instead of losing a life and restarting the level at the last checkpoint.

The thief rabbit Nabbit is also playable in the Mario side of NSMBU Deluxe. He serves as the game's easiest mode, being completely immune to damage from enemies. Nabbit can't use power-ups, and any power-ups he collects in a level get turned into extra lives. Nabbit was originally an enemy in the game, only playable in New Super Luigi U (Toadette is also playable in the New Super Luigi U half of NSMBU Deluxe).

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe

Tempting Two-Pack

Six years after New Super Mario Bros. U and New Super Luigi U came out, they're still excellent games worthy of the Mario name. They don't feel very different from the New Super Mario Bros. games that came out before them, and the few enhancements to the Deluxe version for the Switch don't change that, but they're still responsive, well-designed platformers in the classic side-scrolling style. It's a fun two-game compilation filled with challenge. It isn't a complete masterpiece like the 3D adventure of Super Mario Odyssey, but it will satisfy any old-school Mario fan.

Best Nintendo Game Picks

Further Reading

Final Thoughts

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch) Review - Consumer Electronics

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe (for Nintendo Switch) Review

3.5 Good

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe bundles New Super Mario Bros. U and the much, much harder New Super Luigi U into a single package on the Switch. The combo will satisfy any fan of old-school Mario platformers.

Get It Now
Best Deal£47.19

Buy It Now

£47.19

About Our Expert

Will Greenwald

Will Greenwald

Principal Writer, Consumer Electronics

My Experience

I’m PCMag’s home theater and AR/VR expert, and your go-to source of information and recommendations for game consoles and accessories, smart displays, smart glasses, smart speakers, soundbars, TVs, and VR headsets. I’m an ISF-certified TV calibrator and THX-certified home theater technician, I've served as a CES Innovation Awards judge, and while Bandai hasn’t officially certified me, I’m also proficient at building Gundam plastic models up to MG-class. I also enjoy genre fiction writing, and my urban fantasy novel, Alex Norton, Paranormal Technical Support, is currently available on Amazon.

The Technology I Use

Where to start? I have a standard IT-issued Lenovo Thinkpad for writing and editing, supplemented with an iPad Air and an 8Bitdo Retro Keyboard when I want to write on the go. I also have a Lenovo Legion Go as a platform for running Portrait Displays’ Calman software and controlling the Klein K-10A colorimeter, Murideo SIX-G signal generator, and Leo Bodnar 4K Video Signal Lag Tester I use for testing TVs. 

For gaming, I use a Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X, and a GeForce 5080-equipped MSI gaming laptop. I like collecting retro games as well, and have an Analogue Pocket and a ton of classic consoles and portables. Photography is another interest, and I use a Sony A7 IV when I’m shooting products and events, and a Fujifilm X-Pro3 for my own attempts at visual creativity. And for reading and writing, I’ve become partial to the Kobo Sage for books and the ReMarkable 2 with Type Folio.

When it comes to phones and tablets, I’m pretty platform-agnostic. I use a Google Pixel 8 for my phone and an iPad Air for a tablet. Android, iOS, and iPadOS are all totally fine, but I need a Windows PC. MacOS just isn’t for me.

Read full bio