PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Which AirPods Should You Buy? The Best AirPods for 2023

Apple sells four types of AirPods, including three sets of earphones and one pair of headphones. We compare them all to help you determine which is right for you.

 & Tim Gideon Contributing Editor, Audio

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

You Can Trust Our Reviews

Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. Read our editorial mission & see how we test.

Deeper Dive: Our Top Tested Picks

  • Apple AirPods Pro 2 Noise Cancelling Wireless Earbuds
    Best Noise-Cancelling AirPods Overall

    Apple AirPods Pro 2 Noise Cancelling Wireless Earbuds

    4.5 Outstanding

    Pros & Cons

      • Rich, well-balanced audio performance
      • Excellent active noise cancellation
      • Conversation Aware feature adjusts your music volume when you speak
      • Charging case has a built-in speaker, USB-C port
      • Seamless integration with Apple devices
      • Hearing aid and hearing protection features arriving soon
      • No hi-res codec support
      • EQ presets aren't adjustable

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    The AirPods Pro 2 are the top true wireless earphones for Apple users thanks to their exceptional noise cancellation, excellent sound quality, and advanced audio features.

    Specs & Configurations

    Active Noise Cancellation
    Battery Life Up to 7 hours for earbuds, 28 hours for case
    Charging Support Lightning, MagSafe, Qi Wireless, USB-C
    Chip H2 headphone chip; U1 chip for case
    Connection Type Bluetooth
    Hands-Free Siri
    In-Canal Seal
    On-Ear Controls Volume swipes; press and press-and-hold gestures (ANC/Transparency selection, calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)
    Spatial Audio Personalized Spatial audio with Head tracking
    Transparency Mode Standard and Apdative Transparency
    True Wireless
    Type In-Canal
    Water Resistance IP54 for both earbuds and case
    Water/Sweat-Resistant
    Wireless
  • Apple AirPods Max
    Luxurious Headphones for Apple Lovers

    Apple AirPods Max

    4.0 Excellent

    Pros & Cons

      • Excellent audio performance with rich lows and crisp, detailed highs
      • High-quality active noise cancellation, especially for low-frequency rumble
      • Stunning, unique design
      • Adaptive EQ and Spatial audio
      • Hands-free Siri access
      • Expensive
      • Sound signature and Adaptive EQ/spatial audio aren't for purists
      • No user-adjustable EQ
      • Button placement makes it easy to misfire when adjusting fit
      • Smart Case does little to protect the headphones

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Apple's AirPods Max headphones deliver excellent audio performance, top-notch noise cancellation, and a bevy of useful features in an absolutely gorgeous design for a bit too much money.

    Specs & Configurations

    Active Noise Cancellation
    Battery Life 20 hours
    Charging Support Lightning
    Chip H1 headphone chip
    Connection Type Bluetooth 5.0, USB-C
    Hands-Free Siri
    On-Ear Controls Digital crown (playback, Siri, track navigation, volume); button (ANC/Transparency selecion, pairing)
    Spatial Audio Personalized Spatial audio with Head tracking
    Transparency Mode Standard
    Type Circumaural (over-ear)
    Water Resistance None
    Wireless
    Get It Now
  • Apple AirPods (3rd Generation)
    Best Standard AirPods

    Apple AirPods (3rd Generation)

    3.5 Good

    Pros & Cons

      • Natural, rich bass depth and crisp, clear highs
      • Hands-free Siri voice commands
      • Water- and sweat-resistant design
      • Wireless and MagSafe charging
      • In-ear fit can still be inconsistent, resulting in imbalanced stereo image
      • Fit doesn’t feel secure enough for rigorous exercise
      • No adjustable EQ

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    Apple’s third-generation AirPods provide notably better bass depth and are more rugged than their predecessor. Despite some improvements to how they fit and some neat sensor tricks, we still aren't wild about their open earbud design.

    Specs & Configurations

    Battery Life Up to 6 hours for earbuds, 24 hours for case
    Charging Support Lightning, MagSafe, Qi Wireless
    Chip H1 headphone chip
    Connection Type Bluetooth
    Hands-Free Siri
    On-Ear Controls Force sensor (calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)
    Spatial Audio Personalized Spatial audio with Head tracking
    Transparency Mode No
    True Wireless
    Type In-Ear
    Water Resistance IPX4 for both earbuds and case
    Water/Sweat-Resistant
    Wireless
    Get It Now
  • Apple AirPods (2nd Generation)
    Best for Apple Fans

    Apple AirPods (2nd Generation)

    3.0 Average

    Pros & Cons

      • Crisp, clear audio
      • Excellent wireless charging case design
      • Solid mic clarity
      • Hands-free Siri access
      • Easy pairing
      • Limited on-ear controls
      • In-ear fit and lack of canal seal can feel loose and impact audio
      • No IP rating for water resistance
      • Expensive

    Bottom Line:

    Bottom Line:

    The second-generation Apple AirPods come with a wireless charging case, but do little to justify their higher price or improve upon the shortcomings of the original model.

    Specs & Configurations

    Battery Life Up to 5 hours for earbuds, 24 hours for case
    Charging Support Lightning, Qi Wireless
    Chip H1 headphone chip
    Connection Type Apple H1
    Connection Type Bluetooth
    Hands-Free Siri
    On-Ear Controls Double taps (calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)
    Spatial Audio No
    Transparency Mode No
    True Wireless
    Type In-Ear
    Water Resistance None
    Wireless
    Get It Now
Which AirPods Should You Buy? The Best AirPods for 2023

Compare Specs

Select Up To 3Select Up To 2
Our Pick
Rating
4.5 Outstanding
4.0 Excellent
3.5 Good
3.0 Average
4.5 Outstanding
4.0 Excellent
3.5 Good
Best For
Best Noise-Cancelling AirPods Overall
Luxurious Headphones for Apple Lovers
Best Standard AirPods
Best for Apple Fans
Best Noise-Cancelling AirPods Overall
Luxurious Headphones for Apple Lovers
Best Standard AirPods
Wireless
Water/Sweat-Resistant
Water Resistance
IP54 for both earbuds and caseNoneIPX4 for both earbuds and caseNoneIP54 for both earbuds and caseNoneIPX4 for both earbuds and case
Type
In-CanalCircumaural (over-ear)In-EarIn-EarIn-CanalCircumaural (over-ear)In-Ear
True Wireless
Transparency Mode
Standard and Apdative TransparencyStandardStandard and Apdative TransparencyStandard
Spatial Audio
Personalized Spatial audio with Head trackingPersonalized Spatial audio with Head trackingPersonalized Spatial audio with Head trackingPersonalized Spatial audio with Head trackingPersonalized Spatial audio with Head trackingPersonalized Spatial audio with Head tracking
On-Ear Controls
Volume swipes; press and press-and-hold gestures (ANC/Transparency selection, calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)Digital crown (playback, Siri, track navigation, volume); button (ANC/Transparency selecion, pairing)Force sensor (calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)Double taps (calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)Volume swipes; press and press-and-hold gestures (ANC/Transparency selection, calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)Digital crown (playback, Siri, track navigation, volume); button (ANC/Transparency selecion, pairing)Force sensor (calls, playback, Siri, track navigation)
In-Canal Seal
Hands-Free Siri
Connection Type
BluetoothBluetooth 5.0, USB-CBluetoothBluetooth, Apple H1BluetoothBluetooth 5.0, USB-CBluetooth
Chip
H2 headphone chip; U1 chip for caseH1 headphone chipH1 headphone chipH1 headphone chipH2 headphone chip; U1 chip for caseH1 headphone chipH1 headphone chip
Charging Support
Lightning, MagSafe, Qi Wireless, USB-CLightningLightning, MagSafe, Qi WirelessLightning, Qi WirelessLightning, MagSafe, Qi Wireless, USB-CLightningLightning, MagSafe, Qi Wireless
Battery Life
Up to 7 hours for earbuds, 28 hours for case20 hoursUp to 6 hours for earbuds, 24 hours for caseUp to 5 hours for earbuds, 24 hours for caseUp to 7 hours for earbuds, 28 hours for case20 hoursUp to 6 hours for earbuds, 24 hours for case
Active Noise Cancellation

Buying Guide: Which AirPods Should You Buy? The Best AirPods for 2023

The second-generation AirPods Pro are the latest earphones in Apple's lineup, but they aren't your only option. Here we run you through all of your choices to help you pick the best model for your needs and budget. And for the open-minded, we even suggest some compelling alternatives from other manufacturers.

Make sure to scroll to the bottom of the page for an in-depth specs comparison.


Explore More AirPods Coverage

AirPods Pro (2nd Generation)
Apple AirPods Pro (2nd Generation)

Want to know even more about Apple's AirPods? Check out our explainers on how Adaptive Transparency and Spatial audio work.

About Our Expert

Tim Gideon

Tim Gideon

Contributing Editor, Audio

My Experience

I've been a contributing editor for PCMag since 2011. Before that, I was PCMag's lead audio analyst from 2006 to 2011. Even though I'm a freelancer now, PCMag has been my home for well over a decade, and audio gear reviews are still my primary focus. Prior to my career in reviewing tech, I worked as an audio engineer—my love of recording audio eventually led me to writing about audio gear.

My Areas of Expertise

  • Headphones and earphones
  • Wireless and computer speakers
  • USB mics
  • Bluetooth headsets

The Technology I Use

Probably because of their prevalence in the recording studios I worked in a long time ago, I am most comfortable on Macs—I'm writing this on the 2019 iMac I use for testing. I also have a MacBook Pro that gets plenty of similar use.

My workspace has a mini recording studio setup, and the the gear I work with there is a mix of items I've used forever (Paradigm Mini Monitors and a McIntosh stereo receiver) and newer gear I use for recording and review testing (such as the Universal Audio Apollo x16).

I'm obsessed with modern boutique analog synths—some of my favorites instruments in this realm are the Landscape Audio Stereo Field and HC-TT,  the Soma Enner, the Koma Field Kit, and the Lorre Mill Keyed Mosstone.

From my studio days, I'm comfortable using Pro Tools, and in recent years have branched out to other realms of creative software, like Adobe Premiere and After Effects.

I stream music, but I also still buy albums, digitally or on vinyl, and encourage anyone who wants fair compensation for musicians and engineers to do the same.

I also play lots of Wordle.

Read full bio