PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Amazon: Reading Experience Is the Same Across All Kindle Devices

After its Colorsoft FAQ suggested ebook reading was best on a standard E Ink Kindle, Amazon updates the page to say there's no obvious difference on a color Kindle.

 & James Peckham Reporter

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
(Credit: Emily Forlini)

Don't miss out on our latest stories. Add PCMag as a preferred source on Google.


UPDATE 10/17: Amazon says it has updated its Colorsoft FAQ to "clarify" its position. It now says: "The Colorsoft display is distinct from the Paperwhite display, and includes a full optimized display stack to deliver high quality color reading. The black and white resolution (300ppi) is the same across devices."

Original Story:
The latest frontier for ereaders is the introduction of color screens. However, Amazon is telling prospective buyers that its cheaper, black-and-white products might be best for reading books.

Color ereaders like the Kindle Colorsoft and upcoming Kindle Scribe Colorsoft are designed for those looking to read comic books, graphic novels, magazines, and manga, and to annotate documents such as PDF files. If you're just looking to read the latest bestseller, a color device might not be necessary.

As Good e-Reader reports, the FAQs for the Colorsoft note that its display is "distinct" from the display on its E-Ink Paperwhite.

"The Kindle Colorsoft is designed to provide a high-quality reading experience in both color and black and white. You may notice that the texture or brightness of the display looks different than the Kindle Paperwhite display," Amazon says. "That's because of the color filter layer that creates the easy-on-the-eyes color reading experience on Kindle Colorsoft.

"If you are looking for a slightly crisper black and white reading experience, you may want to check out Kindle Paperwhite, which has the fastest page turns and highest contrast ratio of any 2024 Kindle device," Amazon adds.

Similar wording is found on the Kindle Scribe Colorsoft listing under technical details.

We haven't tested the new Colorsofts yet. The new Kindle Scribe and Kindle Scribe Colorsoft are expected later this year in the US, starting at $499.99 and $629.99, respectively.

Last year, we reviewed the Colorsoft Signature Edition and noted that, "Reading in black and white is less enjoyable. The LEDs placed around the front to light the screen create an uneven effect. It's hard to see when reading in color, but it becomes evident when reading grayscale content."

Initially, PCMag's review unit suffered from an issue affecting many Kindle Colorsofts, where a yellow tint appeared along the bottom of the display. The issue resulted in a five- to six-week delay for many orders as Amazon worked on a fix.

About Our Expert

James Peckham

James Peckham

Reporter

I’ve been a journalist for over a decade after getting my start in tech reporting back in 2013. I joined PCMag in 2025, where I cover the latest developments across the tech sphere, writing about the gadgets and services you use every day. Be sure to send me any tips you think PCMag would be interested in.

I’ve worked at TechRadar, Android Police, T3, and more, where I broke many tech stories you may have read, including the return of the Motorola Razr when it first became a foldable phone. Based near London, I’ve appeared on BBC News, Al Jazeera, and other TV networks, podcasts, and radio shows as an expert on the latest tech stories and trends.

Read full bio