PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Why Can't Copilot Be More Like Cortana?

Given Copilot's advanced capabilities, there's no reason the AI companion can’t handle more practical tasks, like controlling your Windows PC's functions and settings.

 & Michael Muchmore Contributor

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
(Credit: René Ramos; Microsoft; ZinetroN / Adobe Stock)

Few things gave me more pleasure than shouting to turn off my PC for the night from across the living room. No Mac user could simply say, “Hey, Cortana, shut down the computer!” It was just one of the now-defunct Cortana's many capabilities that Microsoft's new Copilot AI doesn't currently replicate.

For those who don’t remember Cortana, it was the first AI-ish voice assistant to appear on a desktop PC, beating Siri on the Mac by more than a year. In addition to shutting off your computer, Cortana could also change system settings, open apps, send emails, and answer general knowledge questions, just like Alexa or Google Assistant. 

I realize that Copilot is a whole different animal than Cortana, with vastly greater knowledge and linguistic skills, but both involve voice interaction with your PC. In fact, a previous version of Copilot had some system control features that overlapped with those of Cortana. However, they are no longer available, which leads me to ask: Shouldn't Copilot, at a minimum, be able to do everything Cortana did?


Why Can't Copilot Control Your Computer?

So, what’s the starting requirement for the kind of functionality I’m looking for? A wake word.

It's true that you can get wake word functionality in Windows via the Voice Access accessibility feature. However, it's most suitable if you want to do everything on your PC via voice rather than just some things. Another difference is that Voice Access can't use AI to find answers and generate content. And unlike with Cortana, tasks like changing system settings and shutting down your computer aren't a one-command affair.

I understand that implementing device control—and especially wake word functionality—is more difficult on mobile devices since Microsoft doesn’t control the hardware features necessary to enable it. But on Windows PCs, that shouldn’t be much of a hurdle since Microsoft has a lot of influence over PC hardware requirements, such as the requirement of a TPM security chip for Windows 11 and an NPU for Copilot+ PCs.  

I’m not even asking for control of various smart home devices like Cortana offered. After all, Microsoft had announced that Cortana would no longer work as a smart device controller toward the end of its life. That's fine; all I’m asking is that Copilot can control the very PC you use it on! 


A Good Sign of Things to Come

Don’t get me wrong: Microsoft has added some very cool things to Copilot recently, including Copilot Vision, which uses multimodal generative AI to observe active windows (on your PC) or your surroundings (via your phone's camera); Copilot Pages, which helps you draft and save persistent documents; and Copilot Search, a supercharged Bing capability that makes its thought processes and sources more transparent than rivals. The company is even experimenting with a Copilot Personalization feature, by which the AI takes on a visual personality.  

From the announcements at Microsoft’s 50th anniversary celebration, it seems like my wish might soon come true. A press release on Copilot Vision states, "You’ll be able to use Copilot to search, change settings, organize files and collaborate on projects without switching between files or apps." However, that seems to pertain only to running apps the AI sees on the screen. Extend this to Windows itself, and I’ll be a happy camper. 

About Our Expert

Michael Muchmore

Michael Muchmore

Contributor

My Experience

I've been testing PC and mobile software for more than 20 years, focusing on photo and video editing, operating systems, and web browsers. Prior to my current role, I covered software and apps for ExtremeTech and headed up PCMag’s enterprise software team. I’ve attended trade shows for Microsoft, Google, and Apple and written about all of them and their products.

I still get a kick out of seeing what's new in video and photo editing software, and how operating systems change over time. I was privileged to byline the cover story of the last print issue of PC Magazine, the Windows 7 review, and I’ve witnessed every Microsoft misstep and win, up to the latest Windows 11.

I’m an avid bird photographer and traveler—I’ve been to 40 countries, many with great birds! Because I’m also a classical music fan and former performer, I’ve reviewed streaming services that emphasize classical music.

Technology I Use

For everyday work, I use a good-old Dell tower with 16GB of RAM, a 12th-gen Intel Core i7 processor, and an Nvidia RTX 3060 Ti GPU that runs on Windows 11. I pair it with a 4K Lenovo ThinkVision P27u-10 monitor and a Logitech MX Vertical mouse. For offsite work, I use a 2024 Microsoft Surface Laptop with a Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite processor. Camera-wise, I moved to mirrorless from a Canon EOS 80D with a Canon 70-300mm IS USM lens. I now have a Canon EOS R7 with a 100-400mm lens, but I miss my DSLR for several reasons.

In order of usage, the software I turn to most frequently is the Edge web browser, Slack, Adobe Creative Cloud, Microsoft 365, Firefox, Brave, and WhatsApp. I use the Windows Phone link app to see everything on my Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra phone, which has excellent telephoto capability.

For fitness monitoring, I have a Fitbit Charge 6 and use an Anker Smart Scale P1. I’m also a streaming fan, so I subscribe to both Amazon Music Unlimited (especially for its Dolby Atmos content) and Qobuz (for its high-res sound quality and classical catalog). I recently added a Vizio 5.1 Soundbar SE, which sounds surprisingly good given its low price. To holler commands instead of using a remote control, I have the Amazon Fire TV Cube in the living room, which lets me verbally tell the TV what I want to watch. It hooks up to an LG B4 OLED TV. I have a Sonos One speaker in my kitchen that also ties in with Alexa, as does the Echo Dot 2 With Clock in my bedroom. For serious listening, I have B&W 601 speakers plugged into a Conrad-Johnson Sonographe amp and preamp, with a Cambridge Audio AXN10 streamer as source. For reading, I also have a Nook GlowLight 3.

Read full bio