Pros & Cons
-
- Blocks most spam.
- Almost no false positives.
- Filters any e-mail account in supported clients.
- Free!
-
- Free edition inserts ad footer into outgoing mail, text ads into toolbar.
SPAMfighter Standard Specs
| Free: | Yes |
| OS Compatibility: | Windows Vista |
| OS Compatibility: | Windows XP |
| Type: | Personal |
Community-based spam filtering leverages the most finely tuned spam detection device in the world—the human brain—and relies on the fact that spam, by definition, is sent to thousands of victims. When enough community members mark a message as garbage, nobody else in the community has to look at that same junk mail. SPAMfighter Standard implements this technique effectively, and it's free for personal use.
You do pay in a way: The program adds a SPAMfighter footer to your outgoing e-mails. You may not mind seeing the ads, but your friends might not appreciate them, and it's certainly not the sort of thing you want in your business e-mails. The software also displays small text advertisements in its toolbar. Pay $29 for SPAMfighter Pro and you get rid of the ads and footer. You also gain the ability to blacklist or whitelist unlimited domains and addresses (the free edition is limited to 100). And the Pro edition can block messages written in specific foreign languages. The Standard edition runs with all of the Pro features enabled for the first 30 days.
The software supports Microsoft Outlook versions 2000 or later, Outlook Express 5.5 or later, and Vista's Windows Mail. Once installed, it filters all incoming mail regardless of the account type, placing nuisance messages in an automatically created SPAMfighter folder. And it installs a toolbar that lets you quickly block or unblock messages and whitelist or blacklist their senders.
As with any community-based spam filter, junk sometimes slips through. When that happens, do your civic duty: Click on the Block button so that your fellow community members won't get spammed. In the unlikely event that this action results in a valid message getting blocked, just click on Unblock.
Like
The blacklist and whitelist feature can override community-based filtering. Mail from a blacklisted address or domain is always blocked, while missives from a whitelisted address or domain are always allowed. You don't need this feature nearly as much as you do when using a spam filter that detects spam by analyzing content, but it's available. Like many antispam products, SPAMfighter imports your address book into its whitelist at start-up and does so again on demand. But here's a nice twist: It can also import the blocked senders list from your e-mail client into the blacklist.
Wonder how well it's working? The software's Statistics page shows how many spam messages it has blocked for you and for the entire community of 5 million users. According to this page, it has headed off over 15 billion spam messages overall.—
Does It Work?
On my test system, SPAMfighter Standard first installed as a 30-day trial of SPAMfighter Pro. I actually tried to trick it into downgrading to SPAMfighter Standard by setting the system date back two months before installation and then setting it forward again, but that didn't work. I carefully avoided enabling the Pro-only language-blocking feature, though, and I mentally pictured a text-only advertising link in the toolbar in place of "Tip of the day."
I made sure the whitelist and blacklist were both empty and then let the program process almost 12,000 messages from three spam-infested e-mail accounts. Downloading that tremendous collection of mail naturally took a while, but SPAMfighter didn't cause any noticeable slowdown. When the process was complete, I faced the arduous task of sorting the Inbox and the SPAMfighter folder each into three categories: undeniable spam, valid mail from individuals, and valid bulk mail such as newsletters. I discarded any messages that didn't clearly fit into one of those categories.
In a similar test, Cloudmark Desktop and iHateSpam didn't mark a single valid message from an individual as spam. I expected that SPAMfighter would do the same, so I was surprised to find one perfectly valid message in the spam folder. It wasn't spam-like at all—in fact, it was a unique message from one of my other e-mail accounts. No other community member could have marked it as spam, so what happened? It turns out that SPAMfighter does use content-based filtering to a small degree. The tutorial even states: "A lot of spam is filtered before it ever hits the community, but how we do that we will keep to ourselves." No matter—a false positive rate under 1 percent is better than what the vast majority of spam filters can manage, and whitelisting would have protected that particular message anyhow.
The product let less than 9 percent of undeniable spam hit the Inbox. That's better than most filters, but not as good as the 95-percent blocking rate promised on the company's Web site. It took me a while to realize what the problem was. Community-based spam filtering works with current spam, but some of the sample messages had been sitting on a server for months. I cleared out all messages older than 30 days (cutting the sample set in half) and ran the numbers again. Now the numbers showed less than 3 percent of the spam reaching the Inbox—just a little bit more than Cloudmark and iHateSpam.
If you need free spam filtering and don't mind having an advertising footer added to all your messages, this is a great solution. It's nearly as effective as the best community-based filters. If, however, you need the features of the $29 Pro edition and are willing to pay for antispam, I'd suggest iHateSpam ($19.95) or Cloudmark Desktop ($39.95) instead.
More Antispam Reviews:
Final Thoughts
SPAMfighter Standard
If you need free spam filtering and don't mind having an advertising footer added to all your outgoing messages, this is a great solution. It's nearly as effective as the best community-based filters. If you need the features of the $29 Pro edition, though, I'd suggest looking at iHateSpam ($19.95) or Cloudmark Desktop ($39.95) instead.