PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Five Reasons Not to Buy a Verizon iPhone 4

 & Wendy Sheehan Donnell Editor-in-Chief, PCMag / VP of Content, Ziff Davis

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

After returning from the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas last week, where communication was key and AT&T voice and data service was virtually non-existent, I'm more ready than ever to toss my AT&T iPhone. No matter what it costs me. Despite loving the actual phone, three years of data dead zones, more dropped calls than I could ever count, and flat-out false signal strength indicators, I'm very bitter. Verizon iPhone? Yes, please. NOW.

Finally, after years of wondering when it would happen, the iPhone has arrived on Verizon. The CDMA iPhone goes on sale on February 10 at Apple and Verizon stores at $199.99 for 16GB and $299.99 for 32GB. Yippee.

Here's my plan: I sell my iPhone on eBay; I bet there are plenty of overseas users who would love to score a bargain on a gently used iPhone 3GS with a SIM card slot, which could easily be unlocked for use on a foreign carrier. Also, since I signed my contract back in 2009 when the 3GS was released, before AT&T upped its termination fees, I'll only have to pay about $75 to get out of that dreaded contract. What I'd get at auction for the old iPhone will surely cover that.

I could have a new iPhone 4 (which is an upgrade for me)—one that works in my apartment, all along the West Side Highway in Manhattan, and at a convention in Las Vegas—in my hot little hands in a month's time. As tempting as this prospect is, I realize it might not make sense for me, or anyone else in the washed-up AT&T iPhone boat, to jump over to Verizon right away. Here's why:

It has a new carrier, but this isn't a new iPhone. The CDMA iPhone that Verizon announced yesterday is the same iPhone 4 that was released on AT&T back in July. Sure it's on Verizon's 3G network, which can look like the promised land if you're used to AT&T's often-subpar 3G coverage in a lot of places. But Verizon is hard at work on building out its 4G network, and could easily announce an LTE (4G) version of the iPhone soon. History has shown us that every year in early summer, Apple announces a new iPhone and it goes on sale in early July. So there's no reason to believe that will change this year, or that the new handset won't be available on both AT&T and Verizon around the same time.

July will be here before you know it. And the longer you wait, the less you have to pay to break your AT&T contract; the fee is prorated, based on how many months you've fulfilled.

Hey Verizon, how much are the plans? One of the most obvious reasons to wait: Verizon hasn't announced its service plans for the iPhone. It's been rumored that the carrier will roll out a $30 per month unlimited iPhone data plan, but at the press event, Verizon's CEO, Dan Mead, wouldn't utter a peep about plan prices. And there was no indication as to when they would be disclosed. Verizon also announced that you could use its iPhone as a mobile hotspot to get other devices online. Cool. That's something AT&T doesn't offer, but we have no idea how much the privilege will cost.

Also, give AT&T some time to respond. Maybe the carrier will shower you with bonuses to keep you as a customer. Then again, bonuses don't mean much if you can't use your phone to call your friends to tell them of your good fortune.

Let Verizon iron out the network kinks before you get there. No one knows how many people will buy Verizon iPhones next month, but a large influx of new subscribers could mean a compromise in network quality in some areas. Hey, it happened with AT&T. Then again it might also be fine, but why not let the early adopters find out? Plus, if a massive number of AT&T iPhone users jump ship, you might wind up with better AT&T service.

AT&T and Verizon may not be your only choices. Now that the AT&T stranglehold has been broken, it's possible that Sprint or T-Mobile might pick up the iPhone later this year. More carriers mean more plans, more one-upping on features, and more overall choices.

The Android army just keeps getting stronger. I know. I know. If you're like me, you're a diehard iPhone user who wouldn't even consider switching from Apple's beloved overflowing-with-apps smartphone. Still, even I'll admit that there were some really interesting Android handsets unveiled at CES this year. Verizon's massive Motorola Droid Bionic, for example, is packed to the gills with features, and it's an LTE phone. The 2011 smartphone landscape is going to be hotter than ever. Innovation abounds, so you owe it to yourself to at least take a look at what's out there before you leap.

About Our Expert

Wendy Sheehan Donnell

Wendy Sheehan Donnell

Editor-in-Chief, PCMag / VP of Content, Ziff Davis

My Experience

I'm the Editor-in-Chief of PCMag.com and the Vice President of Content for Ziff Davis. I oversee the editorial operations of PCMag and ExtremeTech.com, leading more than 65 writers, editors, and contributors, steering PC Labs, reviews, and product coverage, as well as news, expert commentary, and service journalism across the sites.

Back when the first iPhone was released, I started at PCMag as a senior editor covering consumer electronics and mobile reviews. After that, I went on to head up the reviews team as executive editor. And most recently I served as deputy editor, managing PCMag's editorial team and day-to-day operations. I've covered more product releases and have edited more reviews, roundups, and buying guides than any human reasonably should, each and every one contributing to the noble pursuit of helping you find the right technology to fit your life.

Before joining PCMag, I was the managing editor of Computer Shopper. I earned my master's degree in magazine journalism from New York University. (Nope, the irony of witnessing the deaths of both of the print magazines I've managed is not lost on me.)

Though I rarely have the opportunity to write these days, I still crave the rush that comes from crafting the perfect headline and enjoy nothing more than a spirited AP Style debate.

My Areas of Expertise

In my quarter-century-long journalism career, my main areas of focus have been mobile technology and electronics, but I've managed to cover most aspects of consumer and business technology. These days, I spend most of my time strategizing in endless video calls. I'm an ace at sharing my screen and telling people who are already speaking that they're muted.

The Technology I Use

I'm a Mac. Always have been, since my family got our first computer, the Apple IIe, in the early '80s. More irony: I was the first staff editor to use an Apple computer instead of a PC to edit reviews for PCMag. Today, my main computers are a Mac Studio with Pro Display and a 13-inch MacBook Pro. I've carried an iPhone since 2008, and proudly display the click-wheel iPod in my office. My 12-year old stole my iPad a long time ago and now he's eyeing my AirPods. I have more smart devices installed in my home than most people on the planet, and I drive an electric Mini Cooper SE and have become mildly obsessed with EV charging. There's a video game museum in my basement.

The Technology I Use

I'm a Mac. Always have been, since my family got our first computer, the Apple IIe, in the early '80s. More irony: I was the first staff editor to use an Apple computer instead of a PC to edit reviews for PCMag. Today, my main computers are a Mac Studio with Pro Display and a 13-inch MacBook Pro. I've carried an iPhone since 2008, and proudly display the click-wheel iPod in my office. My 12-year old stole my iPad a long time ago and now he's eyeing my AirPods. I have more smart devices installed in my home than most people on the planet, and I drive an electric Mini Cooper SE and have become mildly obsessed with EV charging. There's a video game museum in my basement.

Read full bio