PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

The #1 Mistake People Make Choosing a VPN—and How to Avoid It

Don't let FOMO trick you into signing up for a long-term plan for a service you may not like. I've reviewed VPNs for years and am here to explain why it's so important to try before you buy.

 & Justyn Newman Senior Writer, Security

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
(Credit: Cole Kan/PCMag/ Sarayut Thaneerat/da-kuk/jroballo via Getty Images)

You wouldn't sign a lease on a new car before test-driving it, right? The same should be true when choosing a VPN. Yes, you can often get a better price on a long-term plan, but that doesn't mean you should sign up for one out of the gate.

This article was made possible in part by Proton VPN. It was written and edited independently without partner oversight.

When shopping for VPNs, you’re often presented with limited-time deals and pressured into thinking that once they expire, they'll be gone forever—all you need to do is lock in one, two, or three years right now to save big. Don't do this. I can assure you, those deals will definitely come back around if you don't sign up now, and you don't want to be stuck with a multi-year subscription plan for a service you don't like.


Monthly vs. Yearly VPN Plans

Now, let me be clear: Annual or multi-year VPN plans aren’t inherently bad. You can definitely snag a good deal if you know the service is right for you. Just keep in mind that the best option for you now may not be the same one, two, or three years down the line.

For example, companies can change hands. Small VPNs can get acquired by bigger ones. Governments can issue restrictive laws and content bans. The privacy landscape is a tumultuous one. You want to be able to adapt to these frequent shifts, and it’s not easy to do that when you’re locked into a three-year plan for a service that suddenly no longer works in your country. This reasoning especially applies to any so-called lifetime VPN subscriptions.

Yes, monthly plans are more expensive; companies price them high to direct you toward the long-term plans. But personally, I prefer the flexibility and security of a monthly subscription, and urge you to consider the same.


3 Things to Keep in Mind When Choosing a VPN

The good news is that there are many VPNs out there, and we're here to test them and tell you which ones are worth it. Our list of the best cheap VPNs is a good place to start for newbies and anyone else looking to save money. While we can help narrow down your search and point you to the top deals, the rest is up to you, so be sure to keep the following in mind when shopping:

1. Don’t Give in to the False Sense of Urgency 

Time isn’t running out, and limited-time deals will almost certainly be back again soon. While this tactic isn’t unique to VPNs, it is fairly pervasive among many of the top services. Just keep in mind that these "limited" promotions are anything but. A quick search online is sure to return scores of promo codes, and you can keep an eye on our page for the best VPN deals as we find them.

2. Take Advantage of the Trial Period

This goes hand-in-hand with the above. Don’t skip the trial period or free version just because a deal flashes urgent graphics at you. Most services offer a 30- or 45-day money-back guarantee, and some even have free plans that might offer all you need.

3. Check Out Services That Don't Offer Long-Term Discounts

The surefire way to avoid FOMO over long-term deal pricing is to go with a provider that doesn’t engage in those sales tactics. Mullvad is one of our favorite VPNs in part because it has a straightforward, no-nonsense approach to pricing that's transparent and easy to understand.

About Our Expert

Justyn Newman

Justyn Newman

Senior Writer, Security

My Experience

My writing journey started in 2012 and has taken me through various niches, but my main focus has always been on tech. I contributed to several growing PC hardware and software sites, focusing on gaming, peripherals, and privacy.

As the amount of information we put out on the internet has grown, so have the threats and the tools we use to combat them. With VPNs gaining traction in the late 2010s as a tool for the public instead of just an option for business security, I found myself reviewing countless options in this continuously changing landscape.

This led to my role before PCMag over at WizCase, where I honed my knowledge of VPNs and privacy tools and eventually oversaw all of the content produced. I led a talented team of fellow writers and editors to evaluate VPNs, password managers, antivirus, and parental controls.

The Technology I Use

I love small-form-factor PCs. My current ITX build uses an ASRock B650i motherboard, 32GB of RAM, a Ryzen 5 7600X, and an EVGA 3060 Ti, all nestled within the beautiful LZX-8 case by Lazer3D.

I have that connected to an MSI 34-inch ultrawide as my primary monitor. My second monitor is an older Acer 24-inch that only houses Discord and YouTube Music. Since I spend most of my time writing, I value a good keyboard. I use a Neo65 with Gazzew U4T Silent Bobas. My mouse is a Logitech MX Master 3S. For audio, I have a set of Edifier R1280Ts, or I’ll wear my trusty Sennheiser HD 6XXs. 

For work, I use a Lenovo P14s connected to everything mentioned above. If I'm taking personal work or studying on the go, I use a sticker-bombed Framework 13 powered by a Ryzen 5 7640U. Specifically for drafting fiction, I built a writing ‘cyberdeck’ that connects to my Neo 65 for a Raspbian-powered writing setup with minimal distractions. Regarding mobile devices, I’ve been on the Pixel train since the first one launched, and I am currently using a Pixel 9 Pro.

Outside of computing, I always carry a few key pieces of tech on my person. I have a Kindle Scribe that I use for note-taking and reading the latest speculative fiction. For music, I carry a Walkman NW-A55 with a pair of Rose Technics QuietSea IEMs. I do some light gaming on my re-shelled PSP 3000 running Infinity 2.0 CFW. When I'm not at the computer, you’ll usually find me lugging around my Pentax K1000 with a couple of rolls of Ektar 100 on standby.

Read full bio