We review products independently, but we may earn affiliate commissions from buying links on this page. Terms of use.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta)

 & Davis D. Janowski davis_janowski@ziffdavis.com

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

Yahoo! Local Maps, currently in beta testing, is tailored for those times when you just want to generate a local map or produce directions. The maps generated here are far more interactive than those made in tandem with searches on Yahoo! Local, which is geared toward helping you search for local events or businesses. Keep in mind, though, that what makes the maps interactive is the use of Flash, so you may need to upgrade to the latest free version of Macromedia Flash Player (Version 6,0,79,0 as of this writing; the PC we initially used for testing had Flash 6). There's also a non-Flash, non-beta version of Local Maps, but it lacks a lot of the snazzy effects available in the Flash-y beta version.

The first feature we fell in love with was the inset zoom window on the main page. An easy-to-adjust slider lets you quickly zoom in and out, from 0.2 miles to the entire continental U.S.

The application uses both Tele Atlas and Navteq data and is particularly rich in map content. You won't, however, find the multiple types of map views (such as bird's-eye views, satellite imagery, or hybrid views) you'd encounter at Google Local or Windows Live Local. Yahoo!'s focus has been on the search capabilities and maps themselves. As with Google's maps, you can easily click and drag the maps in Yahoo! Local Maps (beta), though they are a bit slower and less responsive. If you're a registered Yahoo! user, once you've signed in, the service will open a map of your home address as a default jumping-off place.

Another feature we really like—once we'd discovered it—was being able to click and drag the flags on the map we'd generated during searches. Dragging them from the map into the left-hand search pane we could very simply generate a multi-point itinerary. We could also easily change the order and, best of all, we'd end up with a highlighted route on the map.

A Yahoo! representative explained that everything on this page, as well as much that populates the beta version of Local Maps, was created in response to user feedback and requests. When questioned about a lack of some of the more intriguing things found at the other sites, such as the satellite views and other imagery, the response was that these things aren't among the features most requested by Yahoo! users (though a satellite component is in the works).

In fact, our only real criticism of the site is that some things don't show up in search but will show up on the map if you know where they are and zoom in far enough (we can't just pick on Yahoo! here either; all these new map/search sites suffer the same symptoms). For instance, we had the same trouble finding the Intrepid Sea, Air, and Space Museum with Yahoo! Local Maps (beta) that we did with Google. Searching on "Intrepid" brought up lots of businesses with Intrepid in the name, and you could locate the site by digging a bit in the results (under Intrepid Foundation), but you had to dig. Nor could we find the site through combinations of the museum's official name, within quotes or without quotes. Such things can be and generally do get fixed as people provide feedback—one of the truly great aspects of the Web—made even easier by Yahoo!'s "Tell us what you think" feedback box.

We'd have liked a pushpin-type feature on Yahoo! Local Maps (beta) similar to what we found on Windows Live Local. Though a Yahoo! spokesperson told us that it is possible and simple to place multiple markers on our map, we could not figure out how to make the application do this. When you search for a location or business, a marker will be placed there, but that marker is removed when you perform your next search. We also encountered repeated errors when we tried to use a "My Saved Locations" feature.

Even with these hiccups, we really like the over

Yahoo! Icons

The folks at Yahoo! used some pretty intuitive icons to identify their Local and Maps pages.

Yahoo! Local

Yahoo! Local is chock full of our neighborhood's goings on. We couldn't survey more than a smattering of localities, but all those we did check out had lots of info. This is thanks largely to the acquisition of upcoming.org last year, a social event calendar site. You should find plenty of subcategories populating the pages for your town or even neighborhood in some cases. Whether it's what "People are asking about," or "Browse All Categories" (which incorporates Automotive, Computers & Electronics, and 13 other categories followed by breakouts of numerous more specific subcategories nested within them) you should find a great deal to explore. Without question, we found the local experience broader, deeper, and more tailored for our area with Yahoo! Local than any of the other services we reviewed for this story.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Local for New York

We were very impressed with the Yahoo! Local site, though we would like to see the full functionality of the beta Maps page eventually available there.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Beta Map Page

We found the main page of Yahoo! Maps Local Beta well-organized and inviting.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Main Page Choices

We thought the main map page interface was pretty intuitive and easy to navigate and also liked the prominent feedback section at the bottom of the page.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Map Slider

We really liked the slider on the Yahoo! Maps Local beta page. It allows you to very fluidly zoom in on an area.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Intrepid Not Found

One criticism we can level against all the sites is that so much of their focus has been placed on including businesses and have missed the boat (pun intended) on some non-profit attractions and parks. For instance, several different searches failed to turn up a massive landmark here in our back yard along the Hudson River---a veteran World War II aircraft carrier turned museum---the USS Intrepid.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Top 5 Map Questions

One thing we liked in Yahoo! Local Maps beta was the "top 5 questions" listed under the Help menu. One of these, how to map an intersection, something we had a question about. We're hoping that the Yahoo! folks will be integrating some of this info into their interface.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Saved Locations

We tried to make use of the "saved locations feature" within Yahoo! Local Maps beta, and while it seemed to have saved them we got back an error message when clicking on any of them.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): Saved Locations Error

Here's the error message we received when attempting to return to some of our saved locations. As with any beta site you can expect a glitch here and there.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): James Gordon Bennet Park On Map

This one left us scratching our head. Note that the engine couldn't find the park we were looking for on this page, even though it is in fact the unamed park in the lower right-hand portion of the screen. Now look at the next slide.

Yahoo! Local Maps (beta): James Gordon Bennet Park In Slider

It does however appear in the slider window when we zoom out a bit and are no longer searching for it. Hmmmm.

About Our Expert

Davis D. Janowski

Davis D. Janowski

davis_janowski@ziffdavis.com

Davis D. Janowski is Lead Analyst for Web Applications and Software, charged with covering the likes of Google, Microsoft, Yahoo!, and millions of other Internet and Web companies. Prior to this, he served as Section Editor for Consumer Networking, GPS Products, Phones & PDAs (Mobile and VoIP); Associate Editor for Networking Infrastructure; and Associate Editor for Internet Infrastructure. Before joining PC Magazine, Janowski worked as a medical editor, covering epidemiology and infectious diseases, receiving training at the Centers for Disease Control. At one point, he acted as guide for a CDC team, collecting ticks for a study on the origins of human ehrlichiosis in the Florida bush. Before that he made a very modest living as a freelance writer and photographer, covering scuba diving and nautical archaeology.

Read full bio