PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Pokemon Gold & Silver Boxed Copies Don't Contain a Cartridge

Nintendo decided a physical release for these classic games was a good idea, but putting a cartridge in the box wasn't.

 & Matthew Humphries Former Senior Editor

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

Sometimes games companies make decisions that leave me scratching my head and asking "why?" Today, Nintendo is that company after taking the decision to release boxed copies of Pokemon Gold and Pokemon Silver next month across Europe. The twist? Neither box includes a game cartridge.

Nintendo already announced that Pokemon Gold and Pokemon Silver, originally released back in 2001 for the Game Boy Color, would be getting a re-release on the Virtual Console on September 22. 3DS owners can then buy, download, and play both games in their original, unmodified form. However, Nintendo of Europe just announced that they will be releasing "packaged versions" of the games.

Physical copies of these classics would make many gamers, myself included, very happy. But Nintendo decided the box is all that's required to count as a physical "packaged" release. If you purchase and open one of these boxes, all you'll find inside is a code to download the game.

That may be enough for some people, but I must protest. Please Nintendo, don't start classing boxed copies of your games as simply meaning I am buying a box. I want my games, old or new, on actual cartridges so they are not tied to having access to a server for download. Because eventually, those servers will get turned off where as the cartridges I do own (from Game Boy right through to 3DS) all still continue to work.

For now, these boxed copies have only been announced for Europe. However, there's every chance the same deal will be offered in the US.

About Our Expert

Matthew Humphries

Matthew Humphries

Former Senior Editor

My Experience

I started working at PCMag in November 2016, covering all areas of technology and video game news. Before that I spent nearly 15 years working at Geek.com as a writer and editor. I also spent the first six years after leaving university as a professional game designer working with Disney, Games Workshop, 20th Century Fox, and Vivendi.

I hold two degrees: a Bachelor's degree in Computer Science and a Master's degree in Games Development. My first book, Make Your Own Pixel Art, is available from all good book shops.

My Areas of Expertise

  • PC components and system building
  • Raspberry Pi
  • Software development
  • Storage technology
  • Video games and gaming hardware

Read full bio