PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Core i9 MacBook Pro Cooling Problems Kill Performance

Apple was too busy putting a Core i9 chip inside the MacBook Pro, they never stopped to think if they should. All the evidence suggests they definitely shouldn't have because it throttles below the chip's 2.9GHz base clock speed and can be slower than last year's Pro.

 & Matthew Humphries Former Senior Editor

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

The MacBook Pro, as the name suggests, is a laptop aimed at professionals. Or at least, it was. The price is high, but in return you expect to get unrivaled performance in a portable package. With the 2018 MacBook Pro, it looks as though Apple has taken a step too far by offering a Core i9 15-inch model without any consideration of the cooling such a high performance chip requires.

As ExtremeTech reports, the Core i9 processor Apple chose to use inside the MacBook Pro (i9-8950K) has a base clock frequency of 2.9GHz, which is capable of bursting up to 4.8GHz when necessary. However, testing carried out by YouTuber Dave Lee makes it clear the Core i9 can't even maintain 2.9GHz, let alone 4.8GHz. In fact, it ends up running at 2.2GHz due to the heat generated inside the chassis forcing it to throttle.

You may be thinking, "but it's still a very fast laptop, right?" but that's clearly not the case. The thermal throttling is so severe this Core i9 model ends up taking longer to complete tasks than older generation processors. Lee used Adobe Premier Pro as an example, pitting the Core i9 MacBook against a 2017 MacBook Pro using an older Kaby Lake chip with fewer cores. The older laptop was faster by 11 percent!

This isn't a problem with Intel's Core i9, it's Apple's thermal solution. Apple is a company laser-focused on design and offering the thinnest, most beautiful laptops to the detriment of just about everything else. In this case it's cooling that's insufficient, and it means the Core i9 is completely wasted inside the MacBook Pro.

It gets worse, though, as the problem isn't just limited to the Core i9 model. NotebookCheck tested the 2018 MacBook Pro which ships with the Core i7-8850H and experienced similar throttling problems. It remains slightly faster than the 2017 MacBook Pro running a Core i7-7700HQ, but the gap diminishes the more you use the laptop as the heat increases.

What's most frustrating about this for new MacBook Pro owners is, Apple either didn't test the thermals thoroughly enough in these new Pros, or it did and decided the reduced performance was acceptable. Neither of those are acceptable when Apple expects you to pay upwards of $2,399 for the Pro and $2,799 if you want a Core i9.

About Our Expert

Matthew Humphries

Matthew Humphries

Former Senior Editor

My Experience

I started working at PCMag in November 2016, covering all areas of technology and video game news. Before that I spent nearly 15 years working at Geek.com as a writer and editor. I also spent the first six years after leaving university as a professional game designer working with Disney, Games Workshop, 20th Century Fox, and Vivendi.

I hold two degrees: a Bachelor's degree in Computer Science and a Master's degree in Games Development. My first book, Make Your Own Pixel Art, is available from all good book shops.

My Areas of Expertise

  • PC components and system building
  • Raspberry Pi
  • Software development
  • Storage technology
  • Video games and gaming hardware

Read full bio