PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

The New Fitbit Air Is So Comfortable, I Almost Forget I'm Wearing It

After a day of testing, I'd already call the $99 Fitbit Air one of the least intrusive fitness trackers I've worn.

 & Andrew Gebhart Senior Writer, Smart Home and Wearables

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
(Credit: Andrew Gebhart)

I just started wearing the Fitbit Air, but I already like how it feels. The $99 fitness tracker has a screenless design, putting it in direct competition with the Whoop band.

The review unit I received includes the lightweight fabric Performance Loop band in Obsidian (black). Google also sent an extra Performance Loop in Berry (red), and a hardy plastic Active band in Fog (silver). Switching bands is easy. I was able to remove the sensor from the black band and pop it into either of the others in a few seconds. That said, I’ll be sticking with the basic black Performance Loop for now because I prefer its understated look, and it's comfy and lightweight enough that I can almost forget it's there.

The sensor pops in and out of the different bands easily
(Credit: Andrew Gebhart)

As I move forward with testing, I plan to wear it 24/7 for the next few weeks. One of the main tests will be judging its comfort level over that time and how its design compares with Whoop's. Like its main rival, the Fitbit Air is meant to serve as a holistic tracker for measuring activity, exercise, sleep, and stress. It’ll give me more data the longer I wear it, so comfort is important. I'll also evaluate whether it delivers on Google's weeklong battery life estimate with real-world use, and assess the accuracy of its metrics.

Slated for release on May 26, the Air is the first Fitbit-branded tracker since the Charge 6 in 2023. It arrives alongside a rebrand of the company’s app, now called Google Health (available for Android and iOS), and the official launch of the Gemini-powered Google Health Coach.

After unboxing the Air and letting it charge, I set it up via Google Health and reintroduced myself to the AI coach, which remembered some of my workout preferences and schedule quirks from when I first tested it in preview last fall. I conversed with the coach about my goals, and it proposed a new workout plan, taking into account my existing personal training schedule. Some of the responses came through slowly, but it also felt a bit like catching up with a friend. The coach was very responsive to its suggested prompts and pivoted seamlessly when I input more complex replies.

(Credit: Andrew Gebhart)

I don't have much data from the Fitbit Air yet, obviously. I need to spend more time wearing the tracker to see if it can accurately assess my health while remaining unobtrusive. Stay tuned for my full review, and in the meantime, check out the video below for all of my initial thoughts after unboxing the Air.

About Our Expert

Andrew Gebhart

Andrew Gebhart

Senior Writer, Smart Home and Wearables

My Experience

I’m PCMag’s senior writer covering smart home and wearable devices. I’ve been reporting on tech professionally for nearly a decade and have been obsessing about it for much longer than that. Prior to joining PCMag, I made educational videos for an electronics store called Abt Electronics in Illinois, and before that, I spent eight years covering the smart home market for CNET. 

I foster many flavors of nerdom in my personal life. I’m an avid board gamer and video gamer. I love fantasy football, which I view as a combination of role-playing games and sports. Plus, I can talk to you about craft beer for hours and am on a personal quest to have a flight of beer at each microbrewery in my home city of Chicago.

The Technology I Use

I tend to like mixing flavors from various companies. My personal computer is an Apple MacBook Pro. My phone is a Google Pixel 7a. On my wrists are an ever-rotating lineup of the latest smartwatches, and I sometimes wear two at once for testing and extra style. The Apple Watch Ultra 2 is a mainstay on my wrist because I use it as a control for evaluating the accuracy of other devices' fitness metrics. 

I spend plenty of time in front of my entertainment center, which features a 55-inch LG OLED TV, a Yamaha soundbar, a Nintendo Switch, and a PS5. (I insisted on getting the PS5 with the disc slot when they were hard to come by and haven’t used the feature in more than a year.) I thought I’d have given in to temptation and snagged an Xbox to play Starfield by now, but Baldur’s Gate 3 saved me money by distracting me long enough for the Starfield hype to blow past.

I have two cats and sneeze plenty, so I have a Shark Air Purifier to help me fight back against their dastardly, shedding ways.

I use my aforementioned Pixel 7a and a Nest Hub for Google Assistant, an iPhone 16e and AirPods to talk to Siri, and an Amazon Echo Show 5 and Echo Show 15 for Alexa, so I’m not in danger of losing touch with any of the big three digital assistants.

Read full bio