PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Cheap MP3 Players 101

 & Tim Gideon Contributing Editor, Audio

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

You Can Trust Our Reviews

Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. Read our editorial mission & see how we test.

Buying Guide: Cheap MP3 Players 101

Back to School Tech Guide Bug

Headed back to campus and looking to save some bucks on an MP3 player? It's possible to do so without sacrificing quality and the ever-so-important cool factor, but you have to educate yourself. There's no shortage of cheap players out there, and sadly, a lot of them are real stinkers. Fear not, my cash-strapped friend. Here are five up-to-date, reliable, and, yes, stylin' options, all for $100 or less.

These days, there's a lot of competition in the low-priced flash memory-based portable player department. This is good news for you. In the past five months alone, I've seen two Editor's Choices in this field: the excellent Sansa Express and the sleek new Samsung YP-U3. The Express now comes in both 1 and 2 GB capacities and is slightly cheaper than the 2 GB YP-U3. Both players, however, feature fun and simple user interfaces and graphics, built-in USB connectors, FM radio, and voice recording. I happen to favor the YP-U3 slightly because I like its overall design a little more, but they're both worth serious consideration.

The ubiquitous iPod Shuffle can't go without a mention here, especially if you're tied to iTunes. However, if you keep your music in another program, like Windows Media Player, you should definitely check out the Creative ZEN Stone. Sure, it's basically a Shuffle knock-off. Even so, it does have a bit more navigation options and for half the price! (Don't confuse this with the ZEN Stone Plus—a similar player with a screen that doesn't quite deliver the same value for your hard-earned dollars).

Finally, Toshiba recently entered the flash-based realm with the Gigabeat U Series. While it's not an award-winning player (I don't love the screen graphics), it's got a sexy physical design, is easy to navigate, and features line-in recording for stealing, er, sharing songs from your friends' collections.

Now, the question is: should you take the money you save and upgrade the lousy earbuds that always ship with these devices or pay for your textbooks? I'd need a Major in Philosophy and a Minor in Ethics to answer that one. Class dismissed.

In This Roundup:

Samsung YP-U3Class President: Samsung YP-U3
Our latest Editor's Choice, the YP-U3 is stylish and easy-to-use, featuring a pop-out USB connector and touch-sensitive buttons.


Sansa ExpressValedictorian: Sansa Express
Also featuring a built-in USB connector, the Express has two things the U3 doesn't: FM recording and a cheaper price.


Apple iPod Shuffle (2nd generation)Mr. Popularity: iPod Shuffle
The most popular guy on campus looks good, but he has very little self-control.



Creative ZEN StoneCheapest Date: Creative ZEN Stone
This player provides a little more playback control than the Shuffle, and costs a lot less.



Toshiba gigabeat U SeriesBest Dressed: Toshiba Gigabeat U Series
The U Series has line-in recording along with its standard features, all in a snazzy shell that'll turn heads.



Arrow Complete Back-to-School Coverage Arrow

About Our Expert

Tim Gideon

Tim Gideon

Contributing Editor, Audio

My Experience

I've been a contributing editor for PCMag since 2011. Before that, I was PCMag's lead audio analyst from 2006 to 2011. Even though I'm a freelancer now, PCMag has been my home for well over a decade, and audio gear reviews are still my primary focus. Prior to my career in reviewing tech, I worked as an audio engineer—my love of recording audio eventually led me to writing about audio gear.

My Areas of Expertise

  • Headphones and earphones
  • Wireless and computer speakers
  • USB mics
  • Bluetooth headsets

The Technology I Use

Probably because of their prevalence in the recording studios I worked in a long time ago, I am most comfortable on Macs—I'm writing this on the 2019 iMac I use for testing. I also have a MacBook Pro that gets plenty of similar use.

My workspace has a mini recording studio setup, and the the gear I work with there is a mix of items I've used forever (Paradigm Mini Monitors and a McIntosh stereo receiver) and newer gear I use for recording and review testing (such as the Universal Audio Apollo x16).

I'm obsessed with modern boutique analog synths—some of my favorites instruments in this realm are the Landscape Audio Stereo Field and HC-TT,  the Soma Enner, the Koma Field Kit, and the Lorre Mill Keyed Mosstone.

From my studio days, I'm comfortable using Pro Tools, and in recent years have branched out to other realms of creative software, like Adobe Premiere and After Effects.

I stream music, but I also still buy albums, digitally or on vinyl, and encourage anyone who wants fair compensation for musicians and engineers to do the same.

I also play lots of Wordle.

Read full bio