PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

TV Gimmicks Are Dead. 2017 Is the Year of Real Next-Gen Television

Forget 3D and curved screens. 4K and HDR, the specs that actually improve picture quality, are what's important in TVs.

 & Will Greenwald Principal Writer, Consumer Electronics

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

Ever since HDTVs became standard, we've seen several gimmicks to make them stand out while 4K took its time creeping forward. 3D was never really embraced as a vital feature for TVs, and curved screens were rightly dismissed as needlessly expensive aesthetic tweaks. Add the problem of every manufacturer trying to make its own connected TV ecosystem (and the short-lived farce of Samsung's Evolution Kit and the promise of upgrading your TV by buying all-new electronics for it every year) and you have a confusing blend of features that claim to represent the future of television, but fail to prove it.

CES 2017 Bug

I can't promise those days are over, but if CES is any indication, the gimmicks have mostly been swept away in favor of actual, tangible TV advancements. Last year was the first time we recommended 4K TVs for general consumers. This year we can make it official: Next-gen TV is here, and it really is the time to consider replacing your television for a new and completely better one.

4K Is the New Standard
Forget HDTV. 1080p is yesterday's news. 4K (ultra high definition, or UHD, or whatever you want to call the now-standard 3,840-by-2,160 video resolution) TVs are now the standard. You can find some incredibly inexpensive 4K TVs now, meaning there's no reason to even consider a 1080p screen anymore. More importantly, the resolution and the way to transmit that video has become a hard standard with HDMI 2.0 and HDCP 2.2.

We said this last year, and it's even more true now that 4K TVs outnumber 1080p TVs in major manufacturers' lineups: 4K has arrived, and now is the time to get it. The technology has cleared the high-tech hurdle, and prices have fallen from the stratosphere.

HDR Is the New Premium
High dynamic range (HDR) is an important technology that goes with 4K TVs, and is the reason to spend more money. HDR means each pixel has more information determining its light output and color, making a more detailed picture than an SDR signal even at the same resolution. It's a real benefit, and it's striking when it works, making colors appear more lifelike without the cartoonish effect of oversaturation, and letting shadows and highlights retain detail while getting darker and brighter than before.

HDR comes in a few different flavors, like Dolby Vision and HDR-10. Dolby Vision uses metadata to adjust the picture based on what the TV itself is technically capable of displaying, while HDR-10 uses hard values that don't take panel limitations into account. They're two different ways to pursue the same goal, and both can improve picture quality over SDR.

These are still developing systems, with standards being revised and reconsidered fairly often. However, the differences between versions aren't as concrete as the bump in resolution 4K provides, and a good HDR-capable TV will offer a superior viewing experience regardless of what standard it uses. Of course, a spec sheet might claim the TV accepts an HDR signal but not produce very good contrast or wider colors, but that's what we're here for; our lab tests will show you just how bright, how dark, and how colorful a given HDR TV we're testing can get.

Connected TVs are Easy and Forgettable

Smart TV systems were wildly fragmented for years while every major TV manufacturer attempted to make its own custom interface. There are still vestiges of this in LG and Samsung's TVs, but the majority of manufacturers have embraced third party solutions. Google's Android TV and Google Cast platforms, the Roku TV interface, and Amazon's newly released Fire TV television integration offer TV makers feature-filled systems with loads of apps and services without the need to get fancy with custom engineering.

These standard interfaces mean TV makers can focus on the hardware development and leave the software to third parties, resulting in budget TVs that are still loaded with the connected features users want. It also means the constant battle between big name smart TV platforms and the inconsistent availability of apps is effectively over.

And, of course, you can add connected features to any TV with a media hub like an Amazon Fire TV Stick or a Roku Premiere+. Less than $40 will get you a voice remote and Amazon's Alexa, while just $100 buys the ability to stream all the 4K content you want.

Gimmicks are Mostly Dead
3D was sort of fun, but no one wants to wear chunky glasses every time they watch a movie. Curved screens look interesting when you see them at first, but they offer no real benefit to justify the price. TV makers struggled to add appealing bullet points to their TVs while 4K was evolving, and that resulted in some inconvenient and expensive electronics.

For the current generation of TVs, that's mostly over. There are still a few curved TVs, but they're no longer being pushed like the next big thing, and 3D has become a forgotten feature included on some high-end TVs that consistently elicits the response of "Oh, it can do that? Cool, I'll try it out...oh, wait, I already forgot about it."

TV feature lists are largely simpler and more stable, and while new display technology (including various implementations of HDR) can still make the specs sound confusing, but there's less smoke, and mirrors, and fewer bells and whistles to worry about when looking for a new TV. It's not a foolproof or perfect market, but you can now be certain that 4K means 4K across the board, and that your new TV won't have some poorly designed interface that's out of date with useless apps next year.

Of course, that doesn't mean you should shop for TVs without researching them first. That's why we extensively test every TV that comes into our lab, and why you should read our reviews before you finally do take the 4K HDR plunge.

About Our Expert

Will Greenwald

Will Greenwald

Principal Writer, Consumer Electronics

My Experience

I’m PCMag’s home theater and AR/VR expert, and your go-to source of information and recommendations for game consoles and accessories, smart displays, smart glasses, smart speakers, soundbars, TVs, and VR headsets. I’m an ISF-certified TV calibrator and THX-certified home theater technician, I've served as a CES Innovation Awards judge, and while Bandai hasn’t officially certified me, I’m also proficient at building Gundam plastic models up to MG-class. I also enjoy genre fiction writing, and my urban fantasy novel, Alex Norton, Paranormal Technical Support, is currently available on Amazon.

The Technology I Use

Where to start? I have a standard IT-issued Lenovo Thinkpad for writing and editing, supplemented with an iPad Air and an 8Bitdo Retro Keyboard when I want to write on the go. I also have a Lenovo Legion Go as a platform for running Portrait Displays’ Calman software and controlling the Klein K-10A colorimeter, Murideo SIX-G signal generator, and Leo Bodnar 4K Video Signal Lag Tester I use for testing TVs. 

For gaming, I use a Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X, and a GeForce 5080-equipped MSI gaming laptop. I like collecting retro games as well, and have an Analogue Pocket and a ton of classic consoles and portables. Photography is another interest, and I use a Sony A7 IV when I’m shooting products and events, and a Fujifilm X-Pro3 for my own attempts at visual creativity. And for reading and writing, I’ve become partial to the Kobo Sage for books and the ReMarkable 2 with Type Folio.

When it comes to phones and tablets, I’m pretty platform-agnostic. I use a Google Pixel 8 for my phone and an iPad Air for a tablet. Android, iOS, and iPadOS are all totally fine, but I need a Windows PC. MacOS just isn’t for me.

Read full bio