PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

How We Test SMB Servers

 & Oliver Rist Contributing Editor

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

You Can Trust Our Reviews

Since 1982, PCMag has tested and rated thousands of products to help you make better buying decisions. Read our editorial mission & see how we test.

Deeper Dive: Our Top Tested Picks

    Buying Guide: How We Test SMB Servers

    Oliver Rist

    Server testing means digging into benchmark suites. We'll expand this test suite as time goes on, but for this roundup of workhorse machines, we decided to stick with basic CPU and memory stress testing, coupled with a networked file system test to see how the server fared under varying degrees of disk loading over the network.

    After examining several options, we settled on two benchmark test suites. The first is Geekbench 2.0.10 from Primate Labs, a Canadian software development firm. I like Geekbench because it does a thorough job of stressing both the disk and the memory subsystems. Also, it's available across Windows, Linux, OS X, and even Solaris, and it can run in either 32-bit or 64-bit mode, with specific support for both multiprocesser and multithreaded operation. Geekbench returns an overall Geekbench score compiled from all its tests. With only a few machines tested, this number is of limited importance, but it will grow in comparative value as I review more servers. Meanwhile, you can check out existing Geekbench scores on Primate Labs' results browser (a searchable record of submitted scoring results that's already several hundred machines thick).

    In addition to the overall Geekbench score, I consider specific scores for CPU integer and floating-point performance, as well as for memory speed. Geekbench tests each of these subsystems with a variety of single- and (where applicable) multithreaded tests and returns an overall score in each category.

    For disk tests, we decided to stick with the same benchmark suite we've been using for network attached storage (NAS) testing: the IOzone network file system benchmark (iozone.org ). Nineteen years in the making, IOzone is a sophisticated I/O benchmark test that evaluates an overall server solution from the application or file level rather than just from the raw hardware level. That means we configure our IOzone tests to run an I/O stream in a variety of file and block sizes. In this way we can see results in which the client and server caches play a role, as well as instances when files are so large that caches are overloaded, and we can get a sense of raw hardware performance.

    I set IOzone to run files ranging in size from 32MB to as big as each server's RAM complement. Block sizes ranged from 4K to 128K. The traffic this produced included a range of small and medium-size files, forcing the server and its operating system to show their caching smarts. It also let me see what would happen when whopping data files stressed the servers at the bedrock hardware level.

    We'll be tweaking our performance testing over time, especially the IOzone test, which we may run in a multinodal fashion in later reviews to simulate much larger user loads in stepped iterations. If you've got any requests or suggestions along these lines, feel free to drop me an e-mail, at oliver_rist@ziffdavis.com.

    Benchmark Test Results
    Check out the SMB Sever test scores.

    About Our Expert

    Oliver Rist

    Oliver Rist

    Contributing Editor

    My Experience

    I've covered business technology for more than 25 years, and in that time I've reviewed hundreds of products and services and written a similar number of trend and analysis stories. My first job in journalism was with PC Magazine in the 1990s, but I've also written for other enterprise technology publications, including Computer ShopperInformationWeek, InfoWorld, and InternetWeek.

    Between stints as a journalist, I've worked as an IT consultant, software development manager, and marketing executive for several companies, including Microsoft, where I was a senior technical product manager for Windows Server. My focus is on business tech reviews at PCMag, but you can also find me co-hosting This Week in Enterprise Tech on the TWiT.tv network.

    My Areas of Expertise

    The Technology I Use

    My daily workhorse baby is a sleek Dell XPS 13 9310 ultraportable running Windows 11, a recent purchase that still gives me goosebumps when I look at it. When I'm at my desk, I connect it to two honking HP U28 4K displays using Dell's fancy WD19 docking station. When I'm doing personal work or something that's graphics intensive, those 4K displays get shared with my desktop machine, an iBuyPower Pro Gaming PC that uses Windows 10. And when I'm testing a network product, I use a slightly older Dell Precision Mobile Workstation that dual boots between Windows 10 and Ubuntu.

    Being a business tech reviewer, my home network is a little more involved than most. It's based on a business-class Verizon FiOS internet connection, but between that and the rest of the network sits a Ubiquiti UniFi Security Gateway (USG). My wired connections, including my wife's and my PCs, our smart TVs, and printers run off two UniFi Switch 8 boxes, while the Wi-Fi gets handled using three UniFi AP AC Pro access points. Data protection is a combination of my 32TB Western Digital My Cloud Pro P4100 home NAS, a 2TB Dropbox business account, and BackBlaze's backup software.

    The network is managed with UniFi's Cloud Key and Controller software, because I'm a sucker for colorful dashboards and heat maps. I sometimes back that up using a Wireshark instance I've got running on the Ubuntu machine. For work, I'm a Microsoft Office guy. I live in Outlook and use OneNote for practically everything aside from final draft writing. My days at Microsoft also made me Excel and PowerPoint proficient. The latter is where I do most of the work-related graphics chores, though for personal projects I like Adobe Photoshop and Wonderdraft.

    My Wi-Fi network handles all our tablets and phones, as well as all the home automation devices in our ADT Pulse home security system. That said, I've backed that up with a couple of Wyze Cams. My phone is a Samsung Galaxy S10, and my tablet library includes three Apple iPads, an Amazon Fire HD 10, and a Samsung Galaxy Book 13.

    In the misty days of yore, my first PC was a Radio Shack TRS-80 Model 4, and my first mobile phone was a Nokia 8210.

    Read full bio