PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Pages (for Mac)

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

Pros & Cons

Whether you're delighted or dismayed by Apple's completely rewritten Pages app depends on how much you used the older version. Users who invested years of work in the old versions of Pages are complaining loudly in Apple's support forums that essential features have disappeared, at least temporarily, from the current version. If you're a long-term user, you should definitely continue to work with older versions that shipped as part of the iWork '09 office suite—and you'll still have that version on your system even if you download the new version from the App Store. But anyone looking for a Mac-based alternative to Microsoft Word should take a close look at the new Pages—not only because Apple gives it away free to anyone who buys a new Mac or already has an earlier version of the app, but also because the new Pages is impressively intuitive and elegant. It also makes new steps in live collaborative editing.

First Impressions
I'll get back in a moment to the issues caused by Pages' new file format, and by the temporarily-missing features. Meanwhile, here's what you find if you're trying Pages for the first time. Pages is the first word processor that's designed from the ground up for today's wide-screen computers. Back in the day of 4:3 monitors, when you wanted to adjusting formatting or page layout, most word-processors opened a window over the page that hid the text you were changing until you closed the window. Pages now uses a panel at the right of the screen as the place where you control most—not all—the features that used to be either in a top-of-the screen toolbar or in floating "inspector" windows or other pop-up windows. A "tips" buttons shows or hides boxes with advice on how to use major interface features.

When you're editing text, the right panel shows a spacious set of icons and controls for fonts and paragraph layout, complete with the familiar gear icon for advanced typographic features like automatic ligatures (connected letters available in some fonts, like "Qu" with the tail of the "Q" extending beneath the "u"). When you click on a picture, the right panel instantly switches from showing text-formatting functions to showing image-formatting features, and the panel changes again when you're working in a table. The screen is never cluttered with icons for features that you can't use until you move to another part of your document.

Different looks and reduced features
The new Pages does a better job than any other word-processor of simplifying some common tasks. For example, in the old version of Pages, as in Microsoft Word, you had to insert invisible section breaks before you could use different headers and footers in different parts of a document. In the new Pages, you simply click in the header or footer and click a button that says "Start new header/footer here." Unfortunately, Apple took away flexibility when it added ease of use, because the new Pages, unlike the old, won't let you create different headers for left- and right-hand pages. New features support collaboration, so that co-authors and editors can create their own color-coded comments, and simultaneous editing will be available in the browser-based version of the app.

Apple Pages (for Mac) Interface

Pages's new visual design has a lot in common with the minimal visual style introduced in iOS 7, and it's surprisingly effective in Mac OS X. Working in the new panel design is restful and distracting, especially when you compare it with the clutter that the old Pages displayed by default. Unfortunately, the bad old pop-up windows still appear for features like manual spell-checking, but that seems to occur because Pages uses OS X's built-in spell-checking interface—the same one that appears in TextEdit, for example—instead of its own more modern interface. Oddly enough, Find and Replace also appears in a pop-up window, although the old version of Pages included an option to open a side panel that listed all the search hits in a document.

When Apple released the new Pages, user forums erupted in complaints about missing features, including some uniquely valuable features like the ability to select non-contiguous text and select all text formatted with a specific "style." Also missing is the ability to place a graphic inside a table cell and the entire mail merge feature that made it possible to create customized form letters using data from the Address Book app. The same kind of torrent of complaints occurred a few years ago when Apple created a new version of Final Cut Pro with features missing from the old version. Just as most of those missing features eventually made it back into Final Cut Pro X, you can expect missing features to find their way back to Pages. An unanswered question is how long you'll wait for advanced features that Microsoft Word users take for granted, like the ability to compare two versions of a document and highlight the differences between them.

Final Thoughts

 - Office Suites

Pages (for Mac)

None

About Our Expert

Edward Mendelson

Edward Mendelson

My Experience

I've been writing about software and hardware for PCMag for more than 40 years, focusing on operating systems, office suites, and communication and utility apps. I've specialized in everything related to word and document processing, including format conversion, OCR, and PDF apps. In my spare time, I build apps for Macs and Windows PCs that make it easy to run legacy operating systems (such as old versions of macOS and Windows) and work with legacy documents.

I've also written about technology for non-technical publications, such as The New York Review of Books. Before joining PCMag, I reviewed music and sound equipment for audio magazines. In my other career, I'm the Lionel Trilling Professor in the Humanities at Columbia University and write books about modern literature.

The Technology I Use

For work, I use a Lenovo ThinkCentre M901s desktop (one at home, one in the office) and a Lenovo ThinkPad X13 laptop. For everything else, I use an M4 MacBook Air and an M4 MacBook Pro. I also have an iPad Air and a closet full of obsolete ThinkPads and Macs that I use for testing and nostalgia. I still use an iPhone 13 mini because it's the smallest iPhone that Apple still supports.

My speakers are a mix of Bang & Olufsen and Sonos models, driven by a mix of tube-based and solid-state electronics and a WiiM Pro streamer.

Read full bio