PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Apple Also Suing Motorola Over Xoom

 & Chloe Albanesius Executive Editor, News

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

Apple's patent complaint against Samsung in Germany reportedly includes a little nugget that says Cupertino has also sued Motorola over the design over its Xoom tablet.

"Prior to or simultaneously with the motion for a preliminary injunction against Samsung, Apple also filed a complaint with the same court over the design of the Motorola Xoom tablet," FOSS Patents' Florian Mueller wrote in a blog post.

A local German company, JAY-tech, was also included in the suit, Mueller said, pointing to a section of the filing, which is in German.

Motorola did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Motorola might have cause for concern, since the Regional Court of Dusseldorf this week blocked the sale and import of Samsung's Galaxy Tab 10.1 from the European Union, save for the Netherlands, based on Apple's suit. That comes after Apple convinced an Australian court to stop all pre-launch advertising for the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in the country until the Federal Court of Australia resolves Apple's suit against Samsung.

As Mueller notes, however, it's unclear if Apple's German complaint requests a preliminary injunction against the Xoom, though it does request one for JAY-tech's tablet.

"While it's not stated explicitly, I suppose that the complaint against Motorola also asks the court for an EU-wide injunction, but perhaps just for a permanent injunction without a previous preliminary one," Mueller speculated.

It's possible, he continued, that Apple might be too late for a preliminary injunction.

"While Apple appears to place particular emphasis on lawsuits over tablet computers in its European design-related lawsuits, I believe the reason is that a preliminary injunction can't be requested in Germany if the right holder has been aware of an infringement for too long," Mueller said. "There isn't a clear statutory limit, but German lawyers usually discourage such motions unless they are filed within one month of finding out about an infringement. It's possible to get permanent injunctions even against older products, but for preliminary ones there must be a particular sense of urgency. It's possible that Apple has also been aware of the Xoom for too long to file for a preliminary injunction at this stage."

This, of course, would not be the first time Apple and Motorola have battled it out in court. Motorola sued Apple for patent infringement in October over Apple's iPhone, iPad, and iPod touch.  Apple coutersued several weeks later, saying that Motorola multi-touch smartphones use Apple-owned intellectual property.

Mueller published a "battle map" that outlines some of the Apple vs. Motorola patents in question. 

About Our Expert

Chloe Albanesius

Chloe Albanesius

Executive Editor, News

My Experience

I started out covering tech policy in DC for The National Journal, where my beat included state-level tech news and all the congressional hearings and FCC meetings I could handle. I later covered Wall Street trading tech before switching gears to consumer tech. I now lead PCMag's news coverage.

My Areas of Expertise

Getting my start in DC means I still have a soft spot for tech policy; Congressional hearings can sometimes be as entertaining as a Bravo reality show, for better or worse. But PCMag is all about the technology we use every day, as well as keeping an eye out for the trends that will shape the industry in the years ahead (or flop on arrival). I've covered the rise of social media, the iOS vs. Android wars, the cord-cutting revolution that's now left us with hefty streaming bills, and the effort to stuff artificial intelligence into every product you could imagine. This job has taken me to CES in Vegas (one too many times), IFA in Berlin, and MWC in Barcelona. I also drove a Tesla 1,000 miles out west as part of our Best Mobile Networks project. Of late, my focus is on our hard-working team of reporters at PCMag, guiding and editing their robust coverage.

Read full bio