PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Umi, Revue, Kinect: Which Is Best for HDTV Video Chat?

 & PJ Jacobowitz Analyst, Digital Cameras

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS

Logitech yesterday announced the Revue with Google TV, a $299.99 set-top box that lets you access the Web, run Google Android apps, view media from networked computers, and more, all on your HDTV.

In the "and more" category is video calling. In order to video conference with the Revue, you'll have to purchase an additional Logitech TV Cam for $149.99, but you'll be able to place and receive video calls in 720p. The TV cam uses an app called Logitech Vid HD and you can communicate with other Logitech Vid HD users, either with Revue boxes, or Webcam-enabled Macs or Windows PCs. The Revue is available for pre-order and will ship before the end of the month.

Also announced yesterday is a $599 product from Cisco called the ūmi. Compared with the Logitech Revue Google TV product, the Cisco ūmi is all about video calling on your HDTV, and doesn't offer any other features, but it delivers 1080p resolution, compared with Logitech's 720p. The Cisco ūmi's hefty price tag includes the necessary hardware, but also requires a $24.99 per month fee for service. Ūmi users can make calls to other ūmi users or to those on Google Video Chat, which works on Mac, Windows, and Linux PCs. Ūmi is available for pre-order and will ship next month.

In November, Microsoft will also jump into the video-calling game with its forthcoming Kinect motion-based controller The $149.99 Kinect will allow users to play Xbox 360 video games without a controller, but since it requires a camera for motion sensing, it can also handle video calls. If you already own an Xbox, Kinect will cost your $149.99, if not, you can buy a bundle with the console and the controller with camera for $299.99. And you'll need a $49.99-per-year Xbox LIVE Gold membership. There's no word yet on video-call resolution, but Microsoft has announced that Windows users will be able to call other Kinect users and Microsoft Windows Live Messenger 2011. (A Mac version has not been announced.)

If you don't want to wait, Panasonic currently offers Skype on its G Series and VT Series Web-enabled HDTVs, and you can place video calls in 720p. Prices start at $1099.95 for a 42-inch 1080p plasma, but you have to buy an additional $169.95 camera to make video calls. You can communicate with Skype users on Viera Cast-enabled Panasonic HDTVs, or Skype iMac, PC, Linux, or mobile device users.

Price Monthly Fee Video Resolution Who Can You Talk To?
Logitech Revue with Google TV $299.99 for Logitech Revue + $149.99 for Logitech TV Cam None 720p Other Logitech Revue users or Logitech Vid HD users on PCs or Macs
Cisco ūmi $599 $24.99 1080p Google Talk users on Mac, Windows, and Linux
Microsoft Kinect for Xbox 360 $299.99 (Xbox + Kinect Bundle; $149.99 Kinect only) Requires $49.99 per year Xbox LIVE Gold membership Not Announced Windows Messenger Live 2011 users on PCs (no Mac support announced)
Panasonic G and VT Series HDTVs Price of TV + $169.99 for camera None 720p Skype users with compatible Panasonic HDTVs, Macs, PCs, Linux, or Smartphones

About Our Expert

PJ Jacobowitz

PJ Jacobowitz

Analyst, Digital Cameras

PJ Jacobowitz is PCMag.com's Analyst for Digital Cameras. He has been with PCMag.com since September of 2006 and has appeared on MSNBC, CW11, ABCNY, XM Satellite Radio and CNN Radio as a correspondent for PCMag.com. PJ graduated with a Bachelor's degree in Telecommunications and a minor in Business in 2004 from Indiana University at Bloomington. For more information on the photography lab, see "How We Test Digital Cameras."

Read full bio