Pros & Cons
-
- Large, 5-inch screen.
- AAA TourBook and roadside assistance location.
- Multisegment routing.
- Traffic receiver integrated into the case.
-
- Top-of-the-line model, but lacks Bluetooth phone interface and voice commands found on less expensive Maestros.
- No auto-zoom or auto-volume.
Magellan Maestro 5310 Specs
| 3D Lane Assistance: | Yes |
| Built-In Speakers: | built-in |
| Dimensions: | 3.61 x 5.64 x 0.74 inches |
| Display Type: | Touch |
| Flash Memory Type: | SD/MMC |
| Hard Drive: | No |
| Multi Segment Routing: | Yes |
| Power: | Adapter |
| Power: | Battery |
| Preloaded maps: | Yes |
| Supports MP3: | No |
| Turn-by-turn: | Yes |
| Type: | Automobile |
| Type: | PDA |
| Type: | Portable |
| Waterproof: | No |
While most of us are happy with a GPS device that has a 3.5-inch or 4.3-inch (diagonal) screen, there are those who long for something slightly larger. So far, only a few portable GPS devices fill the bill. The ones that immediately come to mind are the
The Maestro 5310 features a 5-inch screen, but that doesn't mean you're getting more information on it. With the same 480-by-272 resolution found on the 4000 series of Maestros, the information on the screen just appears larger, making it easier to view for those in the, ahem, "bifocal set," or for those with an RV. The device measures 3.6 by 5.6 by 0.8 inches (HWD) and weighs 10.2 ounces. That's almost 0.1 inch thicker than the 3000 and 4000 series Maestros, and significantly heavier, to boot. The additional weight is due in part to the larger 2,200-mAh lithium ion battery with a claimed battery life of up to 3 hours. It also includes a built-in real-time traffic receiver.
The 5310 parallels the previous top of the line
Surprisingly, however, the 5310 has fewer features than the 4250. Noticeably missing from the 5310 is the voice-command feature first introduced in the
The user interface on the 5310 is virtually identical to that of earlier Maestros I've reviewed. The main menu has two screens, each with three large icons. The first screen has icons for "Show Map," "Enter Address," and "Points of Interest." At the bottom of the screen, there's an icon that takes you directly to your Home location, as well as a tow truck icon that opens up the AAA Roadside Assistance screen. This screen shows your latitude/longitude, your exact location relative to the nearest streets, and AAA's Roadside Assistance and Membership enrollment phone numbers. As an option, you can enter your AAA membership number, so you don't have to fumble for your membership card should you need to call for assistance.
Like most GPS devicess, the 5310 gives you the option of 3D track up, as well as 2D north and 2D track up views. The map screen is uncluttered, showing just the information you'll probably want. At the bottom of the screen, without an active route, the current time and your speed is displayed. There are zoom in/zoom out icons, a volume control icon, a GPS signal-strength indicator. In the upper-left corner, there's a direction indicator, which, if you tap it, lets you quickly save your current location. The single-tap save of the current location is a feature I wish other GPS units had.
Entering an address for a new destination is very simple. You can enter the city, the ZIP code, choose a previously selected city, pick an address out of your address book, route to an intersection, or choose a previous destination. Once you've entered the information, you are presented with a Route Method screen that lets you select Fastest Time, Shortest Distance, Least Use of Freeways, or Most Use of Freeways. You can also choose to avoid toll roads. The 5310, like the other Maestros, does not have vehicle profiles such as car, truck, bike, or pedestrian. And route avoidances are limited to toll roads. You can't, for example, choose to avoid ferries, U-turns, or unpaved roads. Once your route has been calculated, you can choose to simulate the route at up to 2X real time (that is, it plays back the simulation twice as fast as real time. So if a trip takes 20 minutes, the simulation will take 10 minutes).
With an active route, the map view shows you the distance to your next turn and the name of the street for your next turn. On the lower-right corner of the screen, the data field toggles between remaining time, remaining distance, and estimated time of arrival. The turn-direction graphic in the lower left corner of the screen shows you the direction of your next turn. If you tap that icon, you get a turn-by-turn list view of your route—another nice one-tap feature.—
On the Road
I road-tested the 5310 not only on my standard test routes but also on a trip I recently took to Phoenix. For my standard tests, the routes generated matched virtually all other GPSs that use the Navteq mapping database. In Phoenix, it did get me to my destinations, but since I haven't tested too many devices there, I can't really say whether it found the best routes, or, for that matter, the routes the locals would take. I found I liked the larger screen—it really did make things easier to read—but I think a 5-inch screen is about the maximum size that you'd want to put on your windshield or dashboard. A device much larger might partially block your view.
In both testing situations, I noticed that the 5310 frequently recalculated my route—even if I was following the route and hadn't made any turns. It remains a mystery to me why, for example, it recalculated my route between exits on AZ route 51, only to present me with the same route. This is something that I haven't observed in other Magellan Maestro models.
One of the advantages of the 5310's larger case is its larger speaker, and the larger cavity in which the sound can resonate. The 5310, though it doesn't have auto volume control, has probably the loudest speaker of any device I've recently tested. Even at 80 percent, it was plenty loud—almost too loud—at highway speeds. And unfortunately, it lacks volume control.
As a member of the bifocal set myself, I suspect the Maestro 5310 is targeted at users like me. While I liked the larger screen, at $600 it doesn't represent a good value—especially since it's missing the voice control and Bluetooth phone found in the less expensive 4250. If I were in the market for a Magellan GPS device, I'd give up the larger screen size and opt for the 4250.
More GPS Reviews: