PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

HP Photosmart A716

 & M. David Stone Contributing Editor

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
 - HP Photosmart A716
4.5 Outstanding

The Bottom Line

The HP Photosmart A716 Compact Photo Printer delivers lots of features, great-looking output, and, in an important step forward for HP, nearly waterproof photos.

Buy It Now

Pros & Cons

    • True photo quality at up to 5 by 7 inches and 4- by 12-inch panoramas.
    • Internal hard drive holds 4GB worth of photos.
    • Performance is on the slow side for photo printers.Watch the HP Photosmart A716 Compact Photo Printer Video Review!

HP Photosmart A716 Specs

Color or Monochrome 1-pass color
Connection Type USB
Cost Per Page (Color) 29.2 cents
LCD Preview Screen
Maximum Standard Paper Size 5" x 7"
Number of Ink Colors 3

When I reviewed the ink jet–based HP Photosmart 475 GoGo Photo Printer last year, I basically said it was a nearly ideal small-format printer with all the features you could want. Except one. The output wasn't even slightly water resistant. Pass a photo around on a hot, humid day and it would likely come back smudged. Now the 475 has a sibling—the HP Photosmart A716 Compact Photo Printer ($249 direct)—and HP has not only improved the features that won me over the first time, but added nearly waterproof output too. In short, HP's taken a printer that was close to ideal and made it better.

Despite a change in HP's numbering system, the A716 is a direct descendant of the 475 GoGo, with all the same core features. It can print from a computer, PictBridge-enabled camera, or memory card, or by way of an optional Bluetooth adapter ($59.99 direct). It can print photos as large as 5 by 7 inches, as well as panoramas at 4 by 12 inches. Its internal hard drive can hold hundreds, if not thousands, of photos that you can organize into slide shows. It even lets you preview and edit photos both on its own 2.5-inch color LCD and—thanks to a video-output port and a supplied cable—on a TV.

One big difference between the 475 and the A716 is that the A716 boosts the hard drive capacity from 1.5GB to 4GB, almost tripling the number of photos you can store. As with the 475, when you use the A716's video connection to view stored photos on a TV, you can use the printer's remote control to move through the photos, edit them, and create and view slide shows, almost as if there's a photo album on your TV. But unlike an album, if a friend or relative likes a particular photo you're looking at, you can press a button on the remote and print a copy.

Of course, the key question to ask of any photo printer is, "Does it print good photos?" In my tests the A716 hit true photo quality on every photo, from snowscapes to landscapes to close-ups of faces. I saw a slight loss of detail in light areas on one photo, but the quality was at least as good as you'll get from a local drugstore. Just as important, the photos are essentially waterproof. You may get water stains if you leave drops of water to dry on the surface, but I took one just-printed photo, held it under running water while rubbing it, and wiped it dry without leaving any visible marks.

The A716's print speed is a touch on the slow side, but still well within the range of a typical small-format printer. For 4-by-6 output, it averaged 1 minute 46 seconds on our standard test photos printed from a computer, and took 1:51 to 2:20 (depending on the photo) when printing from a CompactFlash card, a Canon PowerShot S60 camera, or its own hard drive. The Epson PictureMate Deluxe Viewer Edition, our most recent Editors' Choice, was a bit faster, averaging 1:32 on our standard 4-by-6s from a computer and 1:30 to 1:45 printing from a memory card and camera. Printing 5-by-7 photos on the A716 took only a little longer than printing 4-by-6s, at 2:21 to 3:01.

The A716's cost per print is higher than I'd like, but not unusually high. For $34.99 (direct), you can get a pack with enough ink and paper for 120 4-by-6 photos, which works out to 29.2 cents per print. Unfortunately, there's no equivalent pack for 5-by-7s, and HP does not make a cost-per-photo claim for that format.

When I reviewed the 475, I said it had so many strengths that if it weren't for the lack of water resistance, it would be a runaway pick for Editors' Choice. With the HP Photosmart A716 Compact Photo Printer, the company retains the strong features and performance of the 475 and adds water resistance, too. That's enough for it to replace the Epson PictureMate Deluxe Viewer Edition as our Editors' Choice for a high-end, small-format photo printer.

See how the HP Photosmart A716 Compact Photo Printer measures up to similar machines in our photo printer comparison chart.

More photo printer reviews:

Final Thoughts

 - HP Photosmart A716

HP Photosmart A716

4.5 Outstanding

The HP Photosmart A716 Compact Photo Printer delivers lots of features, great-looking output, and, in an important step forward for HP, nearly waterproof photos.

Get It Now

Buy It Now

About Our Expert

M. David Stone

M. David Stone

Contributing Editor

My Experience

Most of my current work for PCMag is about printers and projectors, but I've covered a wide variety of other subjects—in more than 4,000 pieces, over more than 40 years—including both computer-related areas and others ranging from ape language experiments, to politics, to cosmology, to space colonies. I've written for PCMag.com from its start, and for PC Magazine before that, as a Contributor, then a Contributing Editor, then as the Lead Analyst for Printers, Scanners, and Projectors, and now, after a short hiatus, back to Contributing Editor.

I'm pretty sure I'm the only person who worked on every "Project Printer" blockbuster PCMag ever produced, often writing 15 or more reviews for the year's big printer blowout. (I snuck in a single review one year when I was writing a book, strictly so I could keep that claim alive.)

I've always worked for PCMag as a freelancer, which has freed me to take time away to write nine books, be a major contributor to four others, and write for other publications, including Wired, Computer Shopper, Projector Central, and Science Digest, where I was Computers Editor. I also wrote a computer column at one point for The Newark Star-Ledger.

Although I started my career primarily as a science (mostly physics and astronomy) and science-fiction writer (published in Analog), my non-computer-related work runs the gamut from the Project Data Book for NASA's Upper Atmosphere Research Satellite (written for GE's Astro-Space Division) to the script for a video overview of a top company in the gaming industry (that would be gambling, not video games). My books include The Underground Guide to Color Printers (Addison-Wesley), Troubleshooting Your PC (Microsoft Press), and Faster, Smarter Digital Photography (Microsoft Press).

Having covered a wide range of subjects, I've developed a serial expertise in many of them. The ones most relevant to my current work at PCMag.com are all imaging technologies.

The Technology I Use

I buy new PCs for my writing desk infrequently, because it takes a week or more to customize the settings the way I want them. At the moment, I have an HP Envy tower running Windows 10, but it's old enough to have a Windows 7 sticker on it. Its latest lease on a longer life is courtesy of a newly installed 500GB Samsung SSD 870 EVO.

Elsewhere in my house is an assortment of older and newer PCs. The older ones are dedicated to specific tasks, like the one I've been using to slowly digitize all the paper stored in my filing cabinets, while the newer ones are testbeds for printer and projector reviews.

For writing, I use Microsoft Word 2003, because I find it too annoying to take my hands off the keyboard to give mouse commands using the Ribbon. My workhorse printers are a Xerox Phaser 6280 color laser and a Dymo LabelWriter 450 Twin Turbo for labels and stamps. I also have a Canon Pixma iP8720 for printing photos, and a Canon ImageFormula DR-C225 for scanning.

My first computer was bought to replace my IBM Selectric for writing. After rejecting both the IBM PC (which had just been introduced) and the Apple II because of the keyboards, I chose a Vector Graphics Vector 3 CP/M machine with dual floppies. The first MS-DOS machine I was willing to use for writing was the IBM AT, with its much-improved keyboard compared with the original PC and its gargantuan 20MB hard drive.

Read full bio