PCMag editors select and review products independently. If you buy through affiliate links, we may earn commissions, which help support our testing.

Compaq Presario SR5510F

 & Joel Santo Domingo Former Lead Analyst, Hardware

Our team tests, rates, and reviews more than 1,500 products each year to help you make better buying decisions and get more from technology.

Our Expert
LOOK INSIDE PC LABS HOW WE TEST
65 EXPERTS
43 YEARS
41,500+ REVIEWS
 - Compaq Presario SR5510F
3.0 Average

The Bottom Line

The Compaq Presario SR5510F is a decent alternative if you're looking for an inexpensive desktop to handle your basic needs. Then again, a cheap-feeling keyboard, ball mouse, and scads of crapware show that you truly get what you pay for with this budget system.

Buy It Now

Pros & Cons

    • Inexpensive.
    • Spacious 500GB hard drive.
    • Room for expansion.
    • Some crapware.
    • Dodgy keyboard and ball mouse.
    • Only 60-day subscription to Internet Security.
    • No digital card reader.
    • Weak integrated graphics.

Compaq Presario SR5510F Specs

3-D BENCHMARK TESTS 3DMark06 - 1280 x 1024 - Default: 254
Graphics Card: Nvidia GeForce 6150 SE
MULTIMEDIA TESTS - CineBench R10 (xCPU): 4036
MULTIMEDIA TESTS (minutes:seconds) - PhotoShop CS3 Action Set: 0:55
MULTIMEDIA TESTS (minutes:seconds) - Windows Media Encoder Test: 1:22
Operating System: Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium
Primary Optical Drive: Dual-Layer DVD+/-RW
Processor Family: AMD Athlon X2
Processor Name: AMD Athlon X2 5000
Processor Speed: 2.6 GHz
RAM: 2 GB
Storage Capacity (as Tested): 500 GB
SYSMARK 2007 - Preview 3D Modeling: 102
SYSMARK 2007 - Preview Electronic Learning: 90
SYSMARK 2007 - Preview Office Productivity: 93
SYSMARK 2007 - Preview Overall: 98
SYSMARK 2007 - Preview Video Creation: 107
Type: Mainstream
Type: Value

The Compaq Presario SR5510F ($430 direct) is cheap, has a lot of space in its hard drive, and is basically the computing equivalent of an order of McDonalds' Chicken McNuggets. Like the nuggets, the SR5510F is inoffensive, will fulfill your needs with a minimum of fuss, and can appear on the Dollar Menu at a moment's notice. It's not too exciting, but if you need a new PC and want to spend as little as possible, take a look at this middle-of-the-road value system.

The SR5510F comes in a dark case that has more style than competitors like the eMachines T3642, but it's still a tower that will fade into the background on your desk. The system has an exposed DVD burner and a pair of USB ports on the front panel, which are convenient if you're using your PC as a base station for an iPod or other media player. There's a bunch of space inside the case for one each of the following: PCI, PCIe x1, and PCIe x16 cards, an additional optical drive, and an additional hard drive. The system is missing a digital media card reader, something I consider a necessity these days as many people own more than one digital camera and/or cameraphone. Additionally, the Compaq comes with a cheap-feeling keyboard and a ball mouse. Undoubtedly this was done to save money. Then again, HP's budget desktops all come with optical mice and decent keyboards, so why can't Compaq's?

The SR5510F's AMD Athlon X2 5000 processor is enough to keep the unfussy user multitasking with several windows open. The system's 2GB of RAM mean that you can alternate between several open programs with no problem, and you can do light to medium editing on your digital photos and videos. Good thing the desktop comes with a large 500GB hard drive; you won't have to archive any of your music, and the system can hold hundreds of hours of downloaded video.

The system bundles a few programs you might want, along with loads of programs you probably don't. The SR5510F's Norton Internet Security app only offers a 60-day trial period: way too short to be useful when Internet threats evolve quickly. The system also comes with muvee autoProducer Basic (aka trialware), and like the HP Slimline s3500f, autoProducer tries to upsell you to the "full" version for about $70. Other annoyances like an Office 60-day Trial, ads for NetZero, and "My HP Games" powered by WildTangent all conspire to grab more money out of your pocket. On the whole, the crapware-to-useful-app ratio is pretty poor.

The SR5510F is a middle-of-the-road performer on our benchmark tests, clocking in with an average time on both Windows Media Encoder (1:22) and PhotoShop CS3 (0:55). It was just a smidge slower than the more expensive Slimline s3500f. The SR5510F did poorly with 3D graphics, unsurprising considering its price point and relatively inexpensive integrated graphics. It couldn't run our DX10-based Crysis and World in Conflict tests at all, and when I ran both at DX9 for fun, the timedemos we use in our testing looked more like slideshows. You're better off sticking with 3D tasks like editing photos and videos, or web browsing with this machine.

The Compaq Presario SR5510F is cheap: At $430 it is one of the least expensive full-featured PCs I've reviewed lately. It is not a bad desktop per se, but it's also relatively unexciting. The SR5510F probably would've scored a little higher if it hadn't come with so much crapware and ads for stuff like WildTangent, Snapfish and NetZero. As it is, if your computer use is unfussy and undemanding, the SR5510F can get you on the net and rocking to your iPod for a few hundred dollars, and that counts for something.

Check out the HP Compaq Presario SR5510F's performance test results.

More Desktop Reviews:

Final Thoughts

 - Compaq Presario SR5510F

Compaq Presario SR5510F

3.0 Average

The Compaq Presario SR5510F is a decent alternative if you're looking for an inexpensive desktop to handle your basic needs. Then again, a cheap-feeling keyboard, ball mouse, and scads of crapware show that you truly get what you pay for with this budget system.

Get It Now

Buy It Now

About Our Expert

Joel Santo Domingo

Joel Santo Domingo

Former Lead Analyst, Hardware

Joel Santo Domingo joined PC Magazine in 2000, after 7 years of IT work for companies large and small. His background includes managing mobile, desktop and network infrastructure on both the Macintosh and Windows platforms. Joel is proof that you can escape the retail grind: he wore a yellow polo shirt early in his tech career. Along the way Joel earned a BA in English Literature and an MBA in Information Technology from Rutgers University. He is responsible for overseeing PC Labs testing, as well as formulating new test methodologies for the PC Hardware team. Along with his team, Joel won the ASBPE Northeast Region Gold award of Excellence for Technical Articles in 2005. Joel cut his tech teeth on the Atari 2600, TRS-80, and the Mac Plus. He’s built countless DIY systems, including a deconstructed “desktop” PC nailed to a wall and a DIY laptop. He’s played with most consumer electronics technologies, but the two he’d most like to own next are a Salamander broiler and a BMW E39 M5.

Read full bio